What If...? · Season 2 · Episode 7
Hela Found the Ten Rings?
Hello and welcome fellow Marvel fans to the Snark
Industries podcast. I'm John. And I'm Remy. And
we invite you to join us as we work our way through
every Marvel TV show, movie, and crossover. Meaning
if there's a Marvel character on screen, it's
fair game. All categorized in the temporal order
of their setting. By the time we're done, we'll
have built a complete start to finish timeline
of the entire Marvel Cinematic Universe. To accomplish
this goal and to have a bit of fun along the
way, each episode will be split into two parts.
The watch party and the deep dive. If you're
hearing this, you found one of our watch parties.
This is where we sit down with you and experience
a piece of Marvel media together in real time,
celebrating the high points and poking fun at
the low ones, because that's what heroes do.
To get synced up, here's what you'll need to
do. Pull up the movie or episode on your screen
and pause it right as the Marvel logo is prominently
displayed. Then come back here and wait for the
three -tone countdown. On the third tone, press
play, and just like that, we'll be watching together.
Quick note, if your version includes ads, you'll
need to pause us during those breaks to stay
in sync. Once you finish watching along, we encourage
everyone to check out the deep dive as well,
where we will do an in -depth analysis of the
information we just consumed. Most importantly,
we want to thank each and every one of you for
joining us on this incredible journey. We're
not affiliated with Marvel in any way, shape,
or form. We're just fans who are passionate about
these stories and these characters and wish to
share them with everyone in a new and exciting
way. So, sit back, relax, and enjoy this episode
of Stark Industries. I like this intro, comic
book -ish. Yeah, very much. Well, what else is
new? I like how she just casually has me on her
there. Right? So Hela is like if Galadriel kept
the ring. Yeah. You'll have a queen. Yes. That's
a fair point. She's speaking truths right now.
Oh, we've seen that. We know this trick. Yep.
That's where she learned it. See, it all ties
together. Yeah. She's just like her daddy. That's
literally the same move. He even blew it up the
same way. Oh, man. This also looks familiar.
Yeah. Yeah. Same location. Odin does not disappoint.
He just, yeah, same room, same moves. This episode
of What If is what if Odin did the exact same
shit with another kid? Well, 10 ,000 years earlier
or whatever. Yeah, right. That's an exaggeration.
It was only like 4 ,000 years earlier, I think.
Yeah, what is it? This is ancient China, yeah?
Yeah, I'm trying to remember the date. Sometime
in the past. Long time ago. Oh, that's cool.
Oh, hell yeah. I'd say it's like the hammer.
So we're equating Hela's helm to the hammer.
Yeah, though she had the hammer too. I mean,
she got all the toys. In space. Oh, okay, we're
at the title sequence. Makes sense. Space. The
final frontier. Since we're at credits and it
just passed, how do we feel about bearded Thor
versus non -bearded Thor? Traditionally, he's
been non -bearded, but of course, Hemsworth.
Yeah. Yeah, I don't really have much of a preference.
Doesn't make a difference to me. I think the
non bearded Thor was a reflection of the clean
cut sort of mentality that they had when he was
originally made. But in actuality, you know,
Norse tradition, he probably would have been
bearded. Yeah, yeah, that makes a lot of sense.
Watch the watcher. Do you have any what if comics
growing up? I'm going to guess no. I did not.
It's never been. It's never been something that
drew me to it. Yeah, I had a stack. Dude, Jeffrey
Wright's voice is perfect for the Watcher. I
don't disagree. OK, yeah, slow walk. Let's do
it. She took Mandarin as an elective. I mean,
think of how many people she's gone up against
and slaughtered of it. They know hundreds of
languages. You know, I tell you, I just don't
see how to sit down and be like, you know what?
Teach me some basic hellos before I jam this
through you. I guess that's fair. Yeah. Oh, looks
like someone doesn't have your back anymore.
Oh, man, playing that card. She didn't stick
with it long, though. No. So I don't know that
someone with Mjolnir and her helm and the magic
abilities that she has would be that proficient
at hand -to -hand combat. Yeah, why would you
need to learn how to? Right. Right. I'm sure
there was a huge part of the tutelage that involved
that. But how many years has it been since she's
needed it? And did you keep it sharp? It's the
Voldemort paradox. So relying on magic when he
could have just yeeted that baby out the window
and been fine. That's so messed up, but you're
absolutely right. I mean, you know. Oh, man,
that is so wrong. Love it. Would have been for
a very different story. Extremely different story.
I do like the parallels. I mean, this is rather
than Thor and then surrounded by S .H .I .E .L
.D., it's hella surrounded by Chinese terracotta
warriors. Well, they're not terracotta yet. In
the rain, making that face. Mm hmm. Mm hmm. Yeah.
They might be terracotta. Hopefully still. I
know this is their inspiration for sure. Do you
guys hear about all those soldiers that just
stood there forever? Let's make them do that.
But longer. Forever. Yeah. Someone likes Hela.
Put this little outfit on. Oh, man, you see that
face? He was like, let's go. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah.
Someone's someone's got a thing for Hela. I believe
in Bambi, they called it Twitter painted. Really
glad they got Blanchette back for this. Yeah,
very cool. I also need to find out what mascara
she's using because it's really holding. Asgardian.
Yeah. Probably not going to find it at your local
Sephora. Yeah, right. New at Ulta, the Asgardian
collection. Makeup that stays forever. Well,
to be fair. Mm hmm. Oh, boy. Shoot your shot,
my man. Go for it. Right. I mean, that's a that's
a. Really honorable position to give someone
who. Ultimately is just a person right now. Yeah,
but, I mean, you saw her kick a bunch of your
soldiers' asses with no powers. That's fair.
Give her her powers back, guess what she's going
to be able to do? Seems like a good tactical
move, honestly. I suppose it, well, yeah. But
then she bashed his face into a table and jumped
out the window, so that one was over. Then there's
that. Yeah, well. It's a valiant effort. She
got a good rest out of the deal, though, so all
in all. Oh, yeah, yeah. In the positive, I would
say. Although she lost her green and black skin
suit. Yeah, seems so impractical anyway, really.
Oh, this little thing. Forgot about this little
thing. Oh, man. I mean. Talking to its butt.
Looks like a cooked turkey with wings. Turkeys
do have wings. Watu just chilling up there. Well,
little do you know. I'm really trying to get
the mileage out of that joke. I know. But humor
is the best humor. I've always said that. Sorry,
if I'm in a mystical forest and someone tells
me to run, I don't care who it is. I'm running.
Yeah. OK, it's not time for a committee. It's
time to go. Speaking of Harry Potter, it's like
the the Triwizard. Yeah, the maze. We'll see
if Robert Pattinson is dead at the end of this
one. Oh, cinematic. You can't do a horse scene
without doing that slow -mo jump through something.
Well, it's like taking a spaceship out of, well,
a Death Star or something like that. Every single
time you fly it out, you've got to be engulfed
in flames and shoot out the end, right? That's
right. It's the exact same thing. Tropes are
tropes. Oh, she just got punched by leaves. And
her horse runs away. She's like, I'm out. Oh,
maybe not leaves, just too fast. Oh, yeah, that's
cool. Or maybe Punch by Leaves. I'm not on Hella's
side anymore. Nah. I mean, I wasn't to start
with, to be fair. I was just like, oh. Dude,
I love that they made Heimdall black, honestly.
In Norse mythology, he's very racist. So the
fact that he's a black dude in MCU, I love it.
I think it's fantastic. We'll show you guys what
we think about this. Kills me It's forgot all
spiky for a second that was red yeah New girlfriend.
Oh, that's interesting. Mm hmm. It was just like,
yeah, lady, but she does have a kind of similar
outfit to them now with her sleeves ripped off.
Yeah, yeah, I kind of dig it. I'm one of you.
You didn't know. one of us Fending off darkness
with more darkness. The sinister smile at the
end really sold that for me. Yeah, right. You're
right. I'm all in. Yeah. Falkor. Yeah. If you
don't behave, I'm going to feed you to that.
Got a freaking luck dragon. You know what kills
me? We haven't seen Feng Feng Foom in the MCU
yet. I know. I didn't see. Is that Anthony Hopkins?
You know, it doesn't really sound like I was
thinking. It doesn't. It doesn't really sound
like him. Yeah. The Mr. Miyagi treatment. Yep.
Wax on. Wax off. Just breathe. Almost went there.
I'll go there. I don't ever mind going there.
Wherever there may be. One of the things I appreciate
about you, John. Look at this. That's a hell
of a flower. Oh, they're picking up the sheet
tricks. Yeah, see? They've heard about this man
in Wakanda that has lots of sheets. She's like,
aha, and then? No, and then. Oh, well, I'm way
happier now. Fenris Wolf. Hit me with a stick.
This is how Hela became Avatar. Earth. Wind.
Fire. Air. What if Hela was from the Fire Nation?
Now that's a mashup. And she learned origami.
I'm just going to start saying that anytime that
someone does something, you know. Impressive.
Yeah, I don't know. Specifically, though, you
still have a lot to learn. Yeah, yeah. You win
an argument. Not bad. You still have a lot to
learn. Heimdall? Okay. A lot of Star Wars parallels
here. This is Luke leaving Yoda on Dagobah. You
know, when it's not broke, don't fix it. Right.
We back at Troy. It is definitely a similar vibe.
Yeah. He doesn't care that she bashed his face
into the table. How you doing? Yeah, no joke.
Yeah, you really got to give it to Marvel Animation.
Yeah. Yeah. Everything. Yeah. Just wow. Just
wow. I would meddle that a lot between this and
when we see him in the films later. Well, I mean,
you know, it's probably his new girlfriend, Frigga.
His new girlfriend, Frigga. Really, really grounded
him. Yeah. She made me a better man. Gave me
a son. Helped me find another one. You think
that mortal shield would be able to hold up to
Odin's power? Well, that's literally what I was
about to say. With all due respect, these two
and their and their trinkets aren't standing
up to the Allfather. I'm sorry. The rings might
be able to hold a little bit, but it's certainly
not that shield. And that would have been cooked
straight through. Well, it could be a magical
shield in its own right. Fair. It did come from.
That's absolutely true. You're absolutely right.
Airbender Village. Airbender Village. Is that
Kung Lao? No, they said it earlier and I've already
forgotten. Why can I not think of the name of
it? Someone somewhere is making fun of us right
now for not knowing. That's all right. Now you
have two. You broke my stick. I love the rings
floating around, grabbing his shit out of his
hands and everything. It's like, damn it. Damn.
How hilarious would it be in a few episodes,
you know, like Nova or someone is flying and
just this blast from Odin out of nowhere comes
and hits him. Yeah. Sorry, that was way. Whoops.
Oh, fire knives. That's cool. Oh, that's not
good. Hey, we saw where she learned that move.
It's like, where'd you get that from? Odin's
not used to all these fancy Eastern martial arts.
Do we think that Hela could actually control
the Odin spear without his consent? That feels
like that wouldn't happen. I agree. I thought
that same thing, but I was just going to let
it slide. All right. Glad it's not just me. Gungir
is his just as much as Mjolnir, Thor's, etc.
Right. Like that. Yeah, that's not Anthony Hopkins.
No. Yeah, it doesn't sound like him at all. Oh.
That's all she needed. Just like the Mjolnir
and the Destroyer armor, it's Odin and her hat.
Her hat. Yeah. It's like boomers in the younger
generation. Oh, shit. You learned the lesson
I was trying to teach you. That's not good. Yeah.
Well, hold on now. You're not supposed to be
able to do that. Right. Oh, man. You think your
little bracelets are going to protect you against
that? Well, they're doing all kinds of stuff.
Oh. Well. Hello, the white. She's always been
white as far as I know. See what I did there?
I did. It's like the Gandalf transformation.
It is pretty cool. Ascension. Gandalf. Yes, that's
what they used to call me. Hela. Yes, that's
what they used to call me. That's peace. Yep.
Oh, man. Oh, that's a cool way to travel. I love
that. Whoever thought of that clever way of him
running? Brilliant. See, that's why I'm not cut
out for these sort of things. My foot would go
in that ring and I'd fall immediately. That's
another one in the books. That's a good place
to call it. What if? Yeah, we'll see you all
in the deep dive, folks. Diving deep. Oh, man.
In the deep dive. Thank you for joining us in
this episode of the Snark Industries podcast.
To join the conversation and further explore
the Marvel Cinematic Universe with us, head on
over to snarkindustriespod .com. The link will
be in the show notes. But with that, we will
see you in the next adventure.
In an alternate timeline branching from the early history of the Nine Realms, the Allfather Odin deviates from his established path of absolute containment. Rather than imprisoning his firstborn daughter and former executioner, Hela, in the lightless void of Hel to suppress her insatiable bloodlust, he opts for a transformative punishment rooted in humility. This decision serves as the nexus point for a reality where the Goddess of Death is stripped of her divine armor and her necro-powers, then cast down to Midgard to learn the value of life among those she once sought to conquer. Banished to medieval China, Hela finds herself in a world where her titles carry no weight and her physical strength is bounded by mortal limitations, forcing a confrontation with her own identity and the legacy of violence she inherited from her father.
As Hela navigates this unfamiliar landscape, she encounters the immortal warlord Xu Wenwu and the clandestine power of the Ten Rings. Her journey takes her from the fortified compounds of the Ten Rings to the mystical, hidden realm of Ta Lo, where she undergoes a rigorous internal and external transformation under the tutelage of the master Jiayi. This shift from conqueror to student allows Hela to reclaim her agency, ultimately defining her own "worthiness" through the lens of mercy rather than conquest. When the forces of Asgard descend upon Earth to claim the Ten Rings for their own, Hela must stand as a defender of the world she was sent to, leading to a new cosmic order where the armies of Asgard and the Ten Rings unite as liberators rather than oppressors.
Dive further at https://www.snarkindustriespod.com/post/0667-12-19-ce-what-if-season-3-episode-7-hela-found-the-ten-rings
Hello and welcome, fellow Marvel fans, to the
Snark Industries podcast. I'm John. And I'm Remy.
And we invite you to join us as we work our way
through every Marvel TV show, movie, and crossover.
Meaning if there's a Marvel character on screen,
it's fair game. All categorized in the temporal
order of their setting. By the time we're done,
we'll have built a complete start -to -finish
timeline of the entire Marvel Cinematic Universe.
To accomplish this goal and to have a bit of
fun along the way, each episode will be split
into two parts, a watch party and a deep dive.
If you're hearing this, you found one of our
deep dives. This is where we slow things down
and take a more pragmatic, in -depth look at
a piece of Marvel media. We'll walk through the
full plot, explore connections to the wider MCU
and Marvel comics, highlight Easter eggs, unpack
lore, and of course, give you our own personal
thoughts and feelings. Although this episode
stands on its own, it is designed to complement
the watch party. So, if you haven't watched along
with us yet, we highly recommend starting there
first and coming back here for the full breakdown.
Most importantly, we want to thank each and every
one of you for joining us on this incredible
journey. We're not affiliated with Marvel in
any way, shape, or form. We're just fans who
are passionate about these stories and these
characters and wish to share them with everyone
in a new and exciting way. So, sit back, relax,
and enjoy this episode of Stark Industries. Hello,
ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the deep
dive of Snark Industries. We just got through
watching What If Hela Found the Ten Rings, which
is season two, episode seven of the What If series.
John, take it away with the synopsis. And just
as we get into this, a reminder to everyone who's
listening, in order of release, we do this because
we are doing everything in temporal order of
the MCU itself. Yes. It may seem like a weird
jump to go from Wakanda to season two of What
If? But there is a reason for it. And I think
it's a good reason. Because when you have this
all together, you can go down this in order of
when things happen in the MCU in general, which
we're kind of marrying together here. And they
have done as well. So just a little side note.
Yeah, which has been a ton of fun so far. Absolutely.
Three episodes in. It feels good. Definitely.
I think it fits and I don't feel whiplash at
all from this. But anyway, so yeah, just a real
quick breakdown of the episode for those who
didn't join us for the watch party or for those
that did. We have an episode where basically
instead of Odin banishing Hela to hell as she
was being a naughty child, he instead sent her
to Midgard in this ancient Chinese setting. I
believe, Remy, correct my math here, but you
said around 700 CE or AD, depending on who you
subscribe to. 667. Okay. So, yeah, roundabouts
in there. So, you know, this ancient Chinese
culture and we immediately get a look at Ten
Rings being there and where the namesake comes
from. What if Hela found the Ten Rings? And Hela,
in a very parallel... scene and breakdown that
happened in the first thor movie which we will
get to eventually but odin strips of her power
he banishes her to earth he you know whispers
into her helmet whoever be worthy shall possess
the power of hella and tosses it back in the
hole as well and you know we have a very real
parallel here of her trying to find her way she
gets here and immediately kind of you know being
hella wants to take over Tries to fight everyone,
realizes ultimately that without her powers,
she is not useless, but certainly not useful
in the sense of the greater scheme of things.
And we have her sort of having this growth journey
as she meets different people, not only there
within the area itself, Talo, which is where
she's at and where she kind of meets, which is...
referenced in the Shang -Chi movie as well. A
lot of pull -ins from different areas here, but
learns a little bit about herself, a little bit
about, ultimately, what she says is peace. And
it turns out that in doing so, and going to this
sort of mystical safe haven of Ta Lo, Heimdall
loses sight of her, takes this to Odin, who sees
the Ten Rings and everything that's happened
as a sort of threat to all of the Nine Realms,
and brings an army down to take them. And ultimately,
her and Odin clash at the end, and she rises
victorious, sort of ascending into this white
version of herself. You know, her clothes change
and everything else. I believe we've made some
Gandalf references there in the Watch Party.
Oh, absolutely. But, you know, she has all these
things and sort of ascends to this new level,
takes over effectively the throne, sort of merges,
it seems, long term. Asgard and Talo together
and her and everyone else sort of go and protect
the cosmos in that sense. And they even show
a scene where she shows up riding Fenris Wolf
and everyone else is there with her as well,
going and stopping Thanos as he's there on the
planet with child Gamora, giving her the perfectly
balanced dagger that has been the... focus of
a lot of memes since then but ultimately yeah
that's that's kind of where it comes to an end
is you know what if she finds the ten rings and
ultimately the ten rings she finds a person who's
uh yeah still attached yeah still attached you
know which honestly and i hadn't seen this episode
before here but uh wasn't what i expected going
in i you know i thought that she was going to
use and command the ten rings but instead she
did not But yeah, so that's the kind of breakdown
of the What If Hello Found the Ten Rings episode.
And now I think we're going to move on to our
sort of tie -ins section. In the MCU in general,
like I said, there's a lot of parallels drawn
in. Obviously, the what ifs only tie in loosely
to the MCU in general because they don't really
happen. They're all sort of by design of what
if this happened, but it didn't. But still, we
can see tie ins and we can see how everything
kind of comes together. And as I mentioned in
the synopsis, you know, we have the parallels
between this episode and the first Thor movie
where, you know, it's this rebellious child that
needs to learn ultimately her true place in the
universe kind of thing. We see not only the parallels
of her being cast to Earth, we see the parallels
of she wields Bjorn in this episode, which I
thought was. Kind of a strange choice, but it
is there. And then Odin destroys Mjolnir there
in the same exact way that she destroyed Mjolnir
when Thor threw it at her. She threw it at Odin.
Yeah, that kind of happened. I did have curiosities
that because we do not know when Mjolnir was
crafted. Do we do we have a date on that? Because
it would make sense for her to wield that prior
to Thor's birth. Yeah, it's certainly possible.
I mean, you know, I suppose like a lot of things
when you. When you get to something like this,
it'll depend on the writer and the run in the
comic series of when it was actually done. I've
always kind of assumed that it was sort of crafted
for Thor specifically. Yeah, me too. But, you
know, maybe they were going a different direction
here. Not a problem if they were. Of course,
it's what if. Yeah, not even just what if, but
if you zoom out on the scope of all of these.
comic books, stories, movies, TV shows, and everything
else, there are differences and continuity issues
abounds because there are different writers,
different runs, different arcs that they take.
So to me, that's not super problematic as long
as we understand that there are, you know, ultimately
a lot of different universe designations and
a lot of different story arcs within the same
universes that maybe don't, one begets the other
sort of thing. Yeah. And speaking of universe
designations, while we're passing by it, this
one is currently designated as Earth TRN 1092,
in case you were curious. How about that? Carry
on. Get that tattooed somewhere. Yeah, there
you go. So we see these parallels. And then,
of course, we have the parallels. Once she gets
to Earth between this and between Shang -Chi,
we see a lot of the same locations. And everything
else. We see the ten rings. We see the... The
critter without a face? The critter without a
face, yeah. They got a lot of mileage on those
jokes. Yeah, whichever one you want to call it.
The lucky dragon. We see all of these things
sort of tied in. So I believe the tie -ins are
there are just sort of homage to other things
that are happening. Obviously, it intentionally
set itself with its own universe designation
here so that it could exist outside of the...
constraints of the sacred timeline but ultimately
we knew that because this is a what if episode
and it's not doesn't have any real bearing outside
of just entertainment and so we'll we'll get
to that portion in a minute but but first uh
remy let's let's uh go through how these tie
into comic book roots yeah so uh what i picked
up on was of course hella We're to start there.
Her first appearance was in Journey into Mystery
number 102 in 1964. So that is Hela's intro and
the flame blades powers that was introduced in
Jason Aaron's era, which was 2012 to 2014. So
we got to see a little bit of that. And then,
of course, we have the 10 rings, which has been.
modified by the MCU to where Zu Wenwu is in command
of them. So the Ten Rings, of course, as we know,
is originally attributed to the Mandarin. That
is a bit of a problematic character these days.
So when the MCU introduced the Ten Rings, of
course, they side skirted it in Iron Man, and
then they gave the official designation to this
character. So that's kind of the roundabout.
Connection to the comics that we have. Those
are the only three that I really found. Of course,
we've got Fenrir and all of all that jazz. But
those are the three three stories that I really
found solid ground for. Yeah, I mean, you know,
and interesting, definitely to see always how
these things evolve over time. Yeah, absolutely.
Hello for being first introduced 60 years ago
before either of our times and everything else.
It's definitely. Pretty cool. And you did say
something. I kind of actually want to touch on
this a little bit. I'm sure we'll do more of
a deep dive on this when we get to it in Iron
Man 3 and in Shang -Chi. Brace yourself. We're
going to get there, Revy, and you're going to
have to enjoy it. I'll watch it. Yeah, yeah.
But the idea of the Mandarin, you touched on
it. I definitely just want to talk about that
just for a second here as this was tied in here
because the Ten Rings, obviously, for anyone
who's... Been around for a long time and really
knows these stories. Yeah, we're definitely changed
significantly. Not even just taking them from
the Mandarin, who agreed, problematic character,
a bit of a caricature. Definitely a little heavy
on the racism, I believe, in today's climate.
A little bit. And they just sort of did a lot
of major changes, not only to the character itself,
which we have with the Ben Kingsley rendition.
Later on, but also the rings of power themselves
are quite a bit different than before. They were
kind of actually legitimate rings. And now they're
to go back to our episode one talks bangles.
So it's definitely it's definitely interesting.
I think it's probably overall a good change.
I wish some things had been done differently,
especially for such a big, prominent character
as the Mandarin. But I understand why you would
want to distance yourself from such things. Yeah.
So that's that's all I wanted to really say about
that, unless you have something to add. No. And
to the MCU's credit, because the Mandarin is
such a problematic character and and very heavily
rooted in a character and racism and all that
jazz. I'm I'm not mad that they they softened
it. I don't love the way they approached it.
However. I don't know if you've seen Wonder Man
yet, but they did expand upon Trevor's character
and they kind of made it a little bit more acceptable.
They probably should have done it earlier because.
I've hated Iron Man 3 for a decade or more at
this point. I've got a few reasons to dislike
that movie, but we'll get there when we get there.
Oh, for sure. Yeah, we certainly will. But nevertheless,
I do like that they did give him a bit more stability
in the MCU as a whole in both Shang -Chi and
now Wonder Man. So it's a little bit more acceptable
as time goes on. But the jarring change that
they forced. Back when Iron Man three came out
was really difficult to deal with. I did not
love it at all. But moving on from that, this
is normally where we would talk about Easter
eggs. But with a what if episode, I mean, it's
just it's always an homage to a story. Exactly.
It is an Easter egg. So we're obviously not going
to go through all that. But let's let's go with
your thoughts. How do you like it? I will quickly
touch before we get to that. There was one thing
that I did want to mention that I don't think
is canon, and you can correct me if I'm misremembering
or just flat out wrong. But when Hela says, my
dad's new girlfriend, Frigga. Yeah. Which definitely
implies, I mean, you wouldn't talk about your
own mother that way, implies that from this perspective.
Thor is only Hela's half brother. Yeah. Yeah.
Which is an interesting, interesting change.
And I actually don't know if it's a change. I'm
with you. I'm not entirely sure if that's a canon
change or not. I've always understood that they
were actually legitimately siblings. But like
I said, there's so many stories. There's so many
arcs. Yeah. You know, this could have been touched
on before or this could be something new here.
let us know in the comments, you know, kind of
thing. Like if, if we're totally off base here,
but I thought it was interesting nevertheless.
So, all right. Yeah. A hundred percent agree.
Moving on. Do we like it? Do we not like it?
Now I'm going to be a little bit jaded going
into this and, and I'll say it here as this is
the first one. And we have three seasons of this
to go through. I do not like the what if series.
And it's not because I think that they're poorly
made. It's not because that I, you know, think
that there are stories that don't need to be
told. I don't like things that don't have stakes.
I don't like things that story, you know, where
stories don't mean anything. And that's what
these ultimately at the end of the day are. They're
interesting stories, but they exist outside of
the canon, so to speak. They don't add anything
to the overall plot line. They're just little
fun snippets. And I can appreciate that something
is well done. And I think this episode specifically
was well done. I don't like it for those reasons,
you know, and, you know, to get into the little
details, you know, you know, having hella weird
wield Mjolnir, whether or not that was something
that happened before. I didn't particularly like
it. Having her sort of being able to take gun
gear from from Odin and then somehow just wield
his power. Yeah. Strange, you know, very, very
strange kind of thing. So. An interesting story.
Cool to see her sort of rise above being a villain
and be ultimately a hero of sorts in this case,
though there definitely seem to be some touches
of imperialism and stuff like that at the end,
which I don't know. We built a cosmic empire
and then we're taking care of everybody. That
doesn't sound like every dictator. For the greater
good, damn it. Yeah, right. Yeah. So interesting
to see that. Like I said, I mean, it was a fun
story, but ultimately. One that I personally
don't like. And now for an entirely different
take. Well, we were talking before we watched
this episode, how in the last episode we spoke
about how John doesn't like the no stakes stories
and inserting characters in stories that already
exist for no reason. I'm on the exact opposite
end. You never had any. What if comics? I had
a whole stack of them. I loved them. I thought
they were fascinating. So when this show came
around, I was all excited. Some of the episodes
do not hit there. There are some big piles of
junk in there, but there are episodes like this
that really stand out as well told stories. And
I love the opportunity to see what a character
could have been, what a small twist in the story
can do to the overall outcome of the universe
when it comes to this kind of stuff. So I've
always really enjoyed the what if stories like
I had one that was what if the war machine had.
never defeated the living laser. And it was the
weirdest, most bizarre story, but I found it
fascinating. It's like, this is, this is the
kind of stuff I love about Marvel is because
they can take these very simple concepts and
just change one little detail and just, here's
a whole different university. You're never going
to hear the full story for, but here's just one
little drop on the bucket. And I just, I find
that so much fun. So That's what I thought of
it. I thought this episode was absolutely fantastic.
One of the better what if episodes, in my opinion.
There you go. Hot takes for both of us. Maybe,
maybe not hot takes, but good breakdown as always.
And to everyone listening, we appreciate you
as always. Yes, we do. I'm John. That's Remy.
Thank you for listening to Snark Industries,
and we'll see you on the next one. Take care.
Thank you for joining us in this episode of the
snark industries podcast to join the conversation
and further explore the Marvel cinematic universe
with us. Head on over to snark industries, pod
.com. The link will be in the show notes, but
with that, we will see you in the next adventure.
Bam, bam, bam.
Snark Industries takes its first detour into the What If...? multiverse, with a full breakdown of an episode that asks what happens when Odin punishes Hela by banishing her to ancient China instead of straight to Hel. The plot gets walked through in full, from Hela's powerless arrival in the shadow of Ta Lo to her eventual clash with Odin and ascension into something altogether new. MCU parallels are mapped out thoroughly, including the clear echoes of the first Thor film, the Shang-Chi connections, and a closer look at how the Ten Rings made the journey from the Mandarin's fingers to Xu Wenwu's wrists. Comic origins are covered for Hela, her flame blade powers, and the Ten Rings, with a longer sidebar on the Mandarin as a character and the MCU's complicated history of handling him. Personal thoughts land on completely opposite ends, with one host firmly against stories without stakes and the other a lifelong What If devotee, making for one of the livelier debates of the series so far.
Dive further at https://www.snarkindustriespod.com/post/0667-12-19-ce-what-if-season-3-episode-7-hela-found-the-ten-rings
Synopsis
In an alternate timeline branching from the early history of the Nine Realms, the Allfather Odin deviates from his established path of absolute containment. Rather than imprisoning his firstborn daughter and former executioner, Hela, in the lightless void of Hel to suppress her insatiable bloodlust, he opts for a transformative punishment rooted in humility. This decision serves as the nexus point for a reality where the Goddess of Death is stripped of her divine armor and her necro-powers, then cast down to Midgard to learn the value of life among those she once sought to conquer. Banished to medieval China, Hela finds herself in a world where her titles carry no weight and her physical strength is bounded by mortal limitations, forcing a confrontation with her own identity and the legacy of violence she inherited from her father.
As Hela navigates this unfamiliar landscape, she encounters the warlord Xu Wenwu and the clandestine power of the Ten Rings. Her journey takes her from the fortified compounds of the Ten Rings to the mystical, hidden realm of Ta Lo, where she undergoes a rigorous internal and external transformation under the tutelage of the master Jiayi. This shift from conqueror to student allows Hela to reclaim her agency, ultimately defining her own "worthiness" through the lens of mercy rather than conquest. When Odin learns from Heimdall that the Ten Rings possess the power to kill Asgardians, he descends upon Midgard not as a conqueror seeking to claim the rings, but as a ruler acting out of fear, determined to neutralize the threat they represent to his reign. Hela must stand as a defender of the world she was sent to, leading to a new cosmic order where the armies of Asgard and the Ten Rings unite as liberators rather than oppressors.
Reality Designation
This story takes place outside the main Marvel continuity: TRN-1092
Reality numbers are Marvel's official designations.
Where a universe has no official number we follow the Marvel Database and use its Temporary Reality Number (TRN-1092). Where there is neither — official or temporary — at the time we watch it, we assign a Snark Industries number of our own (SI-001).
Characters in the Episode
Milestone: Defeated by Hela
The King of Asgard; functions as the primary antagonist whose fear of the Ten Rings' threat to Asgard drives him to invade Midgard.
Milestone: Reunited with Hela and becomes her steed in her crusade
Hela's wolf companion; shown in flashback being chained by Odin out of paranoia, and reunited with Hela in the epilogue as her steed.
Milestone: Her life is fundamentally shifted from its corse due to the arrival of Hela and Wenwu
Witness to the intervention on Zen-Whoberi; her life trajectory is fundamentally altered.
Guardian of the Bifrost; Alerts Odin of Hela's disappearance, triggering Odin's invasion of Earth.
Master of Ta Lo and mentor to Hela; teaches the philosophy of mercy and internal balance.
A Dijiang from Ta Lo who guides Hela through the bamboo forest's magical defenses.
Milestone: Learns the err of her ways, defeats Odin, and begins her 'Conquest of Peace' with Wenwu
The protagonist of the timeline; transitions from the Goddess of Death to the Goddess of Life/Liberation.
Milestone: His life is fundamentally shifted from its corse due to the arrival of Hela and Wenwu
Appears during the epilogue's invasion of Zen-Whoberi; challenged by the new alliance.
The dragon spirit of Ta Lo; its presence serves as a deterrent against Hela's potential betrayal.
The multiversal observer who narrates the divergence and provides the foundational premise.
Milestone: Meets Hela, defeats Odin, and begins a 'Conquest of Peace'
Leader of the Ten Rings; a warlord who seeks an alliance with Hela.
In-Universe Dates
Odin chaining young Hela's beast
Flashback cut into her Ta Lo training. A child Hela protests, "Father, why did you chain him? He means you no harm," and Odin answers that a king must tame his threats to make them fight for him, "just like his mistress." This is Odin forging his executioner at the outset of the campaign she later clocks at a thousand years, so it sits at that campaign's dawn rather than vaguely before it.
Odin's conquest of the Nine Realms with Hela as his Executioner.
Shown in the opening montage as the world tree's branches fall one by one. Hela puts the campaign at "a thousand years of war," a spoken figure; counted back from the c. 1000 CE present, that span runs from roughly the turn of the era to the present frame.
No specific year is given on screen. The episode is set during Wenwu's active warlord years, before he encountered Ta Lo. In the Sacred Timeline, Wenwu's conquests span thousands of years with the Ten Rings organization founded approximately 1,000 years before the present day, suggesting a rough window of 900–1100 AD for an episode set in medieval China during his active campaigns.
Comic Roots
Where the episode's people and places come from on the page.
Hela first appeared in Journey into Mystery #102 (1964). Her iconic headdress is a hallmark of Jack Kirby’s style. The "Hela the White" costume introduced here serves as a visual antithesis to her classic design, symbolizing her rebirth.
The Ten Rings draw from the "Mandarin’s Rings" first seen in Tales of Suspense #50 (1964). The mystical realm of Ta Lo finds its roots in Thor #301 (1980), which explored the interaction between Asgardian and Chinese deities.
Recommended Reading
Where to go next if the episode left you wanting more.
First appearance of Hela in Marvel Comics. Her original depiction as a cold, imperious ruler of Hel is the baseline from which all later characterizations descend.
Explores what makes gods worthy or unworthy of their power: the central theme of this episode. Hela appears in later arcs of Aaron's run as well.
The most direct comics companion to this episode's premise: Asgardian gods reclaiming power and throne through personal transformation.
Provides background on the Ten Rings organization, Wenwu's legacy, and Ta Lo that contextualizes this episode's setting.
The Mandarin in comics is Wenwu's deepest source material. Understanding the original character clarifies how radically the MCU reimagined him as Wenwu.
The Snark File
Easter eggs, callbacks and technical tidbits.
Thor's Arc
The episode's structural backbone is a deliberate retelling of the first Thor film with Hela in the protagonist role. Like Thor in the Sacred Timeline, Hela is stripped of her powers and cast out from Asgard, with Odin delivering a speech bearing very similar words to the one spoken to Thor, including casting her out "in the name of my father, and his father before." The rain-soaked backdrop, the failed attempt to reclaim her power source, and the lesson in worthiness all mirror Thor's arc beat for beat. The helmet enchantment is a direct translation of the Mjolnir enchantment: power granted to whoever shows the right quality, mercy here instead of worthiness there.
The Mjolnir Reversal
In Thor: Ragnarok, Hela's first act on screen is catching and destroying Mjolnir with one hand. Here, when Hela hurls Mjolnir at Odin in desperation, Odin simply catches it and crushes it with one hand, turning the iconography of that moment directly back on her. What Hela did to Thor's symbol of power, Odin does to hers.
Jiayi and the Ying Li Parallel
Hela's first encounter with Jiayi mirrors Wenwu's first encounter with Ying Li: a Ta Lo warrior who defeats a powerful would-be intruder with seemingly effortless grace before training them in the ways of the realm. Jiayi functions as the Ying Nan of this episode, serving the same spiritual mentor role Ying Nan served for Shang-Chi, but the courtship energy between trainer and student deliberately echoes Wenwu and Ying Li's origin.
The Bamboo Forest
As Hela and her horse venture toward Ta Lo, the trees close in around them, the same supernatural defensive mechanism that forced Shang-Chi's team to abandon their vehicle on the road to Ta Lo. The forest recognizes threats in both timelines. And, of course, Morris the Dijiang, the headless, furry creature from Shang-Chi who guided the heroes to Ta Lo, reprises exactly that function here, finding Hela after she escapes Wenwu's compound and leading her to safety. He remains the MCU's most dependable guide animal across realities.