What If...? · Season 2 · Episode 8
The Avengers Assembled in 1602?
Hello and welcome, fellow Marvel fans, to the
Snark Industries podcast. I'm John. And I'm Remy.
And we invite you to join us as we work our way
through every Marvel TV show, movie, and crossover.
Meaning if there's a Marvel character on screen,
it's fair game. All categorized in the temporal
order of their setting. By the time we're done,
we'll have built a complete start -to -finish
timeline of the entire Marvel Cinematic Universe.
To accomplish this goal and to have a bit of
fun along the way, each episode will be split
into two parts, a watch party and a deep dive.
If you're hearing this, you found one of our
watch parties. This is where we sit down with
you and experience a piece of Marvel media together
in real time, celebrating the high points and
poking fun at the low ends, because that's what
heroes do. To get synced up, here's what you'll
need to do. Pull up the movie or episode on your
screen and pause it right as the Marvel logo
is prominently displayed. Then come back here
and wait for the three -tone countdown. On the
third tone, press play, and just like that, we'll
be watching together. Quick note, if your version
includes ads, you'll need to pause us during
those breaks to stay in sync. Once you finish
watching along, we encourage everyone to check
out the deep dive as well, where we will do an
in -depth analysis of the information we just
consumed. Most importantly, we want to thank
each and every one of you for joining us on this
incredible journey. We're not affiliated with
Marvel in any way, shape, or form. We're just
fans who are passionate about these stories and
these characters and wish to share them with
everyone in a new and exciting way. So, sit back,
relax, and enjoy this episode of Stark Industries.
We get a little tune in the front. Yeah, that
kind of flute music. Little pipes. Oh, this is
the Shakespeare episode. Hamlet. Oh, yeah, this
is the what if the Avengers formed in 1602? Well.
I would imagine they'd really steamroll everybody.
Uh, it can't be good. Oh, that guy's gone. Oh,
maybe not. Got Captain Carter. That's not the
Cap I expected that to be when she said, Cap,
you're up. Cap Carter is the official captain
of the What If series. Really? Did you not watch
any of them? Not many. Oh, man. The first season
was actually pretty solid. It had an overarching
story and everything. If it was America, that
wouldn't happen. I'm sure. Britain always taking
those L's. Man, everyone just bends the knee.
Okay, interesting. Right. What? Okay. I almost
said that. God damn it. I guess you could have
the hotline. So what if the Avengers was founded
in 1602? They would just turn on each other?
So. My issue with this, this one in particular
is what if is always based on off of like a single
hinging event. This is hinging on like everyone
existing back then. And it just, it's weird.
I don't know. This is how I, how you feel about
the rest of the what if series. It is safe. Now
you're feeling, you're really starting to feel
what I'm feeling here. Yes. Feel the anger. Everyone
joined me in thinking these are strange. Oh,
they are. They're very strange. I mean, that's
kind of the point, right? I suppose. I am the
Watcher. Hear me roar. That's a cool shot. All
right. She's always doing something. Right. Of
all the people she could have brought to help
them. Right. No offense to Captain Carter. Damn,
he's tall. Well, he's not got a lot of gravity
weight in them living on the moon and such. Fair
enough. His spinal cord is elongated from that.
It scientifically checks out. Best not to look
into it. the band himself that's right that's
a voice you cannot replicate you can't you can't
deny it Oh, whoa, watch your mouth. Language.
They're looking forward. She's just right there.
Right. No one sees her. That's why she hid on
Fury's left side. Right. Hmm. I don't think that's
Robert Downey Jr. Ant -Man. I just... Yeah. Who
else? Right? Loki. Ah. Let's see who we got.
Is that Cap? Yep. Roger's hood. That's pretty
dumb, man. Oh, they got cakes in that basket.
That's awesome. So she did exist here and they
went and got another one. Yeah. Spare piggy.
And then they got run over by horses. Now they're
going to. This episode also has some butt touching.
That's Sherwood Forest's ass. Sherwood's for
it. Stupid. Oh, man. He's got a Florida lease
on his shoulder. Yes, he does. Big fan of the
Saints. They go marching in. He's a scrawny little
fool. Why is this Steve Rogers all beefy? He
didn't get no serum. He took a very big piece
of bread. I'm sure that was exactly what it was.
Yellow jackets. That's pretty great. A ton of
them. Well, I got some bad news for you about
how gunpowder works. All those little guys would
be dead. No, no, no, they wouldn't. That's not
how airman works. That thing just doesn't follow
physics at all. No, never does. Never does. I
love the voice. That was good. That's great.
Oh, man. And where'd the Pym Tech come from?
Listen, what if? I'm just trying to figure out.
I mean, you need some rules still. What if none
of this made sense? That's the name of this episode.
He just went a little purple. I thought he was
about to Hulk out there for a minute. I think
he might. I know I watched this episode, but
I'm not remembering it at all. Oh, that's cool.
That's the Destroyer. It'd be pretty funny if
Happy Hogan became a Hulk. Hulk Hogan. Oh, man.
I'm going to boo you. I don't even feel bad about
it. Everyone, we get one per episode. I'm good
with that. I really like that design for a old
time. You destroy your armor. Yeah, that's sick.
I like that a lot. Can never whistle like that.
Yeah, I just spit all over everything. Yeah.
Oh, shit. He keeps going purple. I don't remember
anything about him going purple. He's going to
turn into Grimace for McDonald's. Oh, dude, that'd
be awesome. What if the destroyer aimed a little
further down? Right. She would be legless. Captain
No Legs. Oh, that's cool. Skull is the executioner.
That's pretty great. But his arm gets tired of
holding like that all the time. Right. Stop saying
the name of your show, man. They really got to
get the plugs in. They're really getting it in
there this time. Does help. Oh, we got a hallway
fight. That's right. A staple. Mm -hmm. Ah, there
he is. Mm -hmm. No, that's that's Tony's old
mask. That's the Mark one armor. Yeah. Whoops.
Oh. That's not what he said. The subtitle said
something different. They're doing the best they
can. Yeah, apparently. Some poor subtitle or
somewhere. He's listening to this like, man,
I tried. I'm so glad that in all the iterations,
Hulk pants just decide that they don't want to
rip off with the rest of his clothes. It really
changed. Stretchy pants. How will y 'all look
at him? The Ed Norton Hulk where he gets the
purple pants and he holds it up and it's all
stretchy and hilarious. It was a funny joke.
Stretchy. Stretchy. So what? It's Hogan, right?
Steve, my hero. It's borderline criminal to not
have Robin Hood be Hawkeye. Right? That was my
expectation as well. He's not even here. Yeah.
Nope. Time for another rift. Go Wanda, go Wanda,
go, go. Sometimes you just got to shoot magic
into another magic and hope that something magical
happens. Must have been a ton of fun for Favreau
to do the English accent and everything. The
old English. Oh, dude, I like his his home, too.
Yeah, that is cool. Make a hole. What kind of
lowly guard is going to go and face a Hulk? Right?
It's weird that when they do it modern day, but
at least they have guns and stuff. These are
just guys with swords. Swords, yeah. Not going
to do a damn thing against the Hulk. No, I'm
just going to go home. He's been trying to protect
that feather this whole time. Well, he did indeed
go purple. What the hell? Man, I must have fallen
asleep during this episode or something. remember
any of this. Well, I'm equally as confused and
this is my first time, so any of the case. You
know, if we've learned anything lately, they
don't like giving away their stuff. That would
have surprised me. Pretty soon you're going to
have Ol' Condon in your mix trying to take it
back. Yeah. Huh. Jesus. Okay. That was a line.
That was something else. Blah. Should have said
hashtag first. I mean, with that. The. Yeah.
What is this garbage? What is this purple nonsense?
Why is Hogan all of a sudden this purple monstrosity?
Did I miss something? What if? See how that works?
The beauty of it is that it hinges on one thing,
though. The one thing here is what if we made
up everything? I just don't understand. Why didn't
they just get Blonsky? He could have been the.
Yeah, I don't know. Could have gotten Abomination
to do this fight. Would have been great. And
made some sense. We're not here to make sense.
We're here to ask, what if? The pipes are calling.
Oh, there it is. Hit him with a treason. He's
playing double duty now. Gonna get some hex tech
up in here. I'm gonna start using that one. In
what world could Thor beat Wanda? This guy. I
don't like anything about this guy. Well, if
it makes you feel any better, he doesn't like
you either. I'm okay with that. Dude, that is
like Hextech. I was just kidding. All right.
Oh, it's Cap. Yeah, and you tried to kill it,
fool. Blast him. So anyways, I started blasting.
Oh, can't help but laugh out loud. It's so bad.
I don't like him. Why they didn't use Blonsky
is so far beyond me. He pressed her right on
the button. Yeah. Well, you did it. Uh -huh.
Whatever it is. Oh, it's him again. Uh -huh,
uh -huh. Sense and a theme. Dun, dun, dun! All
right. Please don't. I mean, yeah. All right,
folks, we will see you over in the deep dive
for this episode. It's going to be a fun one.
I have a feeling. Thank you for joining us in
this episode of the Snark Industries podcast.
To join the conversation and further explore
the Marvel Cinematic Universe with us, head on
over to snarkindustriespod .com. The link will
be in the show notes. But with that, we will
see you in the next adventure.
In an alternate universe set in the year 1602, Captain Peggy Carter is summoned by that world's Scarlet Witch to help prevent the reality from collapsing in on itself. She arrives to find familiar heroes and villains transplanted into the early 17th century, serving under Queen Hela... until a rift tears open and pulls Hela through it, leaving Carter blamed by Thor and declared a fugitive.
Forced to operate outside the law, Carter enlists the era's Tony Stark to engineer a solution and teams up with a Robin Hood-styled Steve Rogers and his band of outlaws. Using a Time Stone-powered gauntlet built by Stark, she uncovers the source of the collapsing timelines: Rogers himself, who cracked the Time Stone during a battle with Thanos in the present day and was sent back to 1602 without his memories. Restoring the reality comes at a personal cost, requiring Carter to say goodbye to yet another version of Steve Rogers.
Dive deeper at https://www.snarkindustriespod.com/post/1602-07-15-ce-what-if-season-3-episode-8-the-avengers-assembled-in-1602
Hello and welcome, fellow Marvel fans, to the
Snark Industries podcast. I'm John. And I'm Remy.
And we invite you to join us as we work our way
through every Marvel TV show, movie, and crossover.
Meaning if there's a Marvel character on screen,
it's fair game. All categorized in the temporal
order of their setting. By the time we're done,
we'll have built a complete start -to -finish
timeline of the entire Marvel Cinematic Universe.
To accomplish this goal and to have a bit of
fun along the way, each episode will be split
into two parts, a watch party and a deep dive.
If you're hearing this, you found one of our
deep dives. This is where we slow things down
and take a more pragmatic, in -depth look at
a piece of Marvel media. We'll walk through the
full plot, explore connections to the wider MCU
and Marvel comics, highlight Easter eggs, unpack
lore, and of course, give you our own personal
thoughts and feelings. Although this episode
stands on its own, it is designed to complement
the watch party. So, if you haven't watched along
with us yet, we highly recommend starting there
first and coming back here for the full breakdown.
Most importantly, we want to thank each and every
one of you for joining us on this incredible
journey. We're not affiliated with Marvel in
any way, shape, or form. We're just fans who
are passionate about these stories and these
characters and wish to share them with everyone
in a new and exciting way. So, sit back, relax,
and enjoy this episode of Stark Industries. Hello,
ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the Deep
Dive 4 episode. What if the Avengers assembled
in 1602? John, you want to give us that synopsis?
I do. Begrudgingly. This has got to be one of
the most confusing bits of Marvel entertainment
that I've ever consumed. So I'll try to walk
us through it. and everything but i don't know
how well i even understood it so by all means
if anyone else listening has some better clarity
on what we're talking about here feel free to
correct us because this was a doozy so we start
out and we see uh loki performing a little bit
of hamlet in front of queen hella and thor and
a few others and this rift opens in the sky And
it seems like this is some sort of big event
that these people living back in the 1600s were
having to deal with. Captain Carter is also there,
which tries to save Hela as she is being sucked
up into this vortex and is unable to do so. And
upon her being gone, I suppose that the rule
of the crown goes to her brother Thor, and his
first act as king is to then imprison Captain
Carter. who is not fulfilling her role because
it turns out she was summoned to this land from
another land that was also old timey, but not
really fitting because she's the only one that
could help. So the Avengers of this land were
able to open a portal to a different land via
the Scarlet Witch. And it's not really clear
how she was meant to help, but the Scarlet Witch
believes that Captain Carter is going to be there.
of getting out of this rift mess. Well, I mean,
who could have gotten Steve involved as well
as her? Fair enough. Fair enough. So we cut to
the prison and she has this discussion with Uatu
about how this world was meant to die. She should
just let it. She, you know, does what heroes
do and says, no, I'm going to help this place
and breaks out of prison. frees the hulk who
is also there and together they make their way
toward the throne room it appears not before
stopping along the way and consulting tony who
is building some sort of device to help them
ultimately find what they call the forerunner
which is whoever is responsible for all this
rift stuff in the first place it's not clear
who it is but Tony is able to build a device
that he says will help. Now, all the main characters
find themselves at the throne room. A fight ensues
between, ultimately, Thor, the Scarlet Witch,
and his royal guard. And then, ultimately, who
is our group of heroes? We've got Captain America.
We've got Captain Carter. We've got Ant -Man.
I believe Bucky was there. The Hulk was there.
Tony was there. We have a very cool action scene.
where they're having this fight, and ultimately
they're able to take the scepter. Wanda sort
of shows that she is kind of playing double agent
here as one of these rifts opens up above the
throne room itself and tries to help them complete
Tony's device by taking the scepter that Thor
was using and placing the jewel from it into...
this device that tony made which turns into a
gauntlet which fires ultimately what is the equivalent
of repulsor blast but it seems to be some sort
of hex technology she takes it or captain carter
puts it on her hand fires it at thor which doesn't
seem to do anything to thor but instead illuminates
captain america steve in this green shimmering
light revealing that he is in fact the forerunner
and he has gotten there from the main universe
by clicking the time stone with his shield while
he's fighting Thanos in Wakanda. And they have
a tender moment where they don't want to lose
each other again as in both of their worlds,
they had lost each other in some way, but ultimately
Steve walks up and just touches the button of
the gym that was in placed in this as a power
source to this Tony head instead of touching
butts, he's touching buttons and everyone in
the room, seems to disappear with the exception
of Captain Carter, who still remains. And then
we have the ending scene where she's talking
to Iwatu again, saying, are you here to gloat
that I'm stuck here forever because she saved
a world that was ultimately meant to be dying?
And to cap things off, very similar to our last
episode, Strange Supreme shows up attempting
to recruit yet another. So whatever this is building
to, I assume some future project. We now have
Kahori and Captain Carter tied into whatever
this Strange Supreme is. Strange is building
a team. Building a team for something. But I
suppose we'll get there. Yep. How this ties into
the MCU in general. Man, I don't even know if
I have the energy to talk about how it does it
and how it shouldn't. This episode, you know,
as I've... Clearly stated before and will continue
to state, what if is not my favorite because
it's so ridiculous. This one really took the
cake for me. It doesn't, the tie -ins, I mean,
I guess the only tie -in we have at all is all
of this sort of hinging off of Steve clicking
the time stone when he was fighting with Thanos.
Right. But even then, how did all these other
people get, none of it made sense. It doesn't
tie in. I don't want it to tie in. Are we also
to believe that vibranium can damage a time stone?
I don't know what I want to believe. I don't.
None of it makes sense. I don't want to take
anything from this episode. I'm good. I don't.
The continuity here doesn't follow. It doesn't
track. It was an interesting episode that had
some cool, you know, 1600 vibes. You know, we'll
get to that a little bit more when we get to,
to, you know, what we like kind of portion of
the show, but sure. In terms of how it ties in,
it just doesn't, it shouldn't. And it doesn't.
That being said, I'll kick it over to you to
talk about the same sort of thing with comic
books outside of the screen. Yeah, yeah. So for
comic book tie ins here, there aren't a lot.
It is, as John said, a what if episode that has
very little impact on the greater Marvel Universe.
However, there was of note a Neil Gaiman storyline
called Marvel 1602 that was published in 2003.
Comparing it to that, there are certainly some
parallels, but what if took its liberties all
over the place? So even using that as a basis,
there's not a whole ton to actually tie it to
as far as true comic source goes. There are certainly
parallels, like I said, but not that substantial.
But Easter eggs, now that there were a lot of
there were quite a few things that I caught and
quite a few things that I researched. One of
them was. that uh peggy says we never get our
happy ending uh right before steve disappears
which is you know how many times have we seen
peggy and steve not get that happy ending this
is the third time i think even with uh within
what if and uh we've got of course strange supreme's
arrival which as we said probably building up
to something but i also wanted to point out the
Iron Man Mach 1 mask. I know I mentioned it in
the watch party. I love that the Hulk was wearing
that as the man in the iron mask in the cell.
That was just so many literary references and
everything. Just fantastic. That one was good.
And I loved that Loki's portrayal of a Shakespearean
actor was. In this, because if you remember,
I think it was Ragnarok where Matt Damon is playing.
Yes. Loki. Yes. And it all just kind of kind
of meshes together. That was cool. That part
was fun. I really enjoyed that. But so why don't
you go ahead and just lay it on thick? What do
you think? So I think that it's very clear to
anyone who's been listening for this entirety
of this deep dive. I did not like this. It was
strange. It did not follow. The what if scenario
didn't didn't make sense because obviously it
pivoted on Steve hitting the time zone. How did
everyone else get there? You know, why is why
is hell of the king? Where did the Pym Tech come
from? The queen. You know what? You know what?
Yeah. Where did the Pym Tech come from? Why is
Happy Hogan a big purple monster? What is that?
You know, that's my biggest problem. There's
so many there's so many layers to it. You know,
and I suppose if you're making Steve the forerunner,
maybe it makes sense that you would have Peggy
be, you know, his antithesis to be able to fix
things. But also, if the Scarlet Witch is summoning
anyone from any timeline to come and help, you
know, I said at the watch party, no offense to
Catherine Carter, but anybody else probably would
have been better suited in terms of power scaling.
But ultimately, that's not what they were going
for, which maybe was the point. I think that
this is an episode that if you took what it does
and removed the parts of it that we're familiar
with, it might have been entertaining. There
were some parts that I liked. I liked the destroyer
armor. I liked, you know, seeing some of these
characters, you know, Red Skull as the executioner
was really neat. That was cool. Seeing these
different. you know, these different sort of
artistic representations of characters that we
all, you know, said we're familiar with being
a certain way and seeing them in this sort of
almost fantasy setting, I thought was very cool.
Ultimately, I think if you took the story that
they told and replaced everyone with people you
didn't really know, it might be serviceable.
It's still pretty loose with plot, honestly.
Still clicking, yeah. But, you know, maybe then,
but when you've got characters that have certain...
paths in life and and you know things that you
would expect for them and then everything is
just so strangely weird you know when you've
got i mean even so much as when you've got hella
and loki and thor having a you know a happy family
unit it seemed like yeah you know to the point
where you know when she's the you know when hella's
the queen and she and she gets sucked into this
portal that you know Thor is ready to defend
her to no end kind of thing. These parts of these
characters, it's just to go so far off script
for seemingly no reason. Minus the fact that
Happy is a big purple monster, why is he aligned
with Thor against ultimately who are considered
the heroes here? You know, Tony, his best friend,
his best Tony, his best friend. Yeah. None of
it makes sense. I just, you know, no, I I did
not like this episode. I don't have anything
good things to say about it. You don't say, you
know, I just I'll pick it up from here. Yeah.
By all means, please take this from me before
I spiral. I also didn't care for this episode.
It was. Of what we've watched so far, this is
the lowest of the rung. I don't understand why
Hogan was a purple beast, why they didn't use
Blonsky to to bring the abomination if they were
already bringing all these characters. And why
the hell not? That's that's an excellent and
makes a little bit more sense for him turning
into this monster. Why Hawkeye wasn't Robin Hood.
What is that? I mean, come on. Scratching an
infinity stone with vibranium. I don't buy it.
I do so many things. I didn't love it. I'm with
you. That being said. Like you mentioned, the
costume design and the reimagination of some
of these characters was really cool. Visually,
it was really, really neat to see. I really enjoyed
that. But all in all, I think this is, let's
call it a subpar episode. Yeah, I like that.
I like that. Subpar. Leaves some to be desired.
Yeah, just a bit. Just a bit. But hey, at the
end of the day, for sake of continuity. Maybe
worth a watch if you're going through the What
If series or following along with us. You know,
you can make fun of it. It wasn't all bad. It
just didn't make a whole lot of sense. Yeah.
Yeah. Turn off your brain. You have to. There
you go. There you go. All right, folks, we will
see you in the next one. Thank you so much for
listening. Thank you for joining us in this episode
of the Snark Industries podcast. To join the
conversation and further explore the Marvel Cinematic
Universe with us, head on over to snarkindustriespod
.com. The link will be in the show notes. But
with that, we will see you in the next adventure.
Zoop.
Snark Industries tackles what both hosts agree is the most confusing entry in the What If...? series so far, and neither of them is especially thrilled about it. The full plot gets walked through as clearly as the episode itself allows, from Loki performing Shakespeare in front of Queen Hela and Thor to the cascading chaos of a reality-tearing rift, Captain Carter's reluctant heroism, and the eventual reveal that Steve Rogers is the forerunner responsible for all of it after accidentally striking the Time Stone with his shield during the Battle of Wakanda. Comic connections to Neil Gaiman's 2003 Marvel 1602 storyline are noted, though the episode takes enough liberties that the parallels only go so far. Easter eggs get their due, including the Hulk wearing an Iron Man Mach 1 mask as the Man in the Iron Mask, Loki's Shakespearean performance as a callback to Thor Ragnarok, and the now familiar sight of Strange Supreme appearing at the end to recruit yet another hero. Personal thoughts are in rare alignment, with both hosts landing firmly in the subpar camp, united in their appreciation for the costume design and equally united in their complete bafflement at nearly everything else.
Dive deeper at https://www.snarkindustriespod.com/post/1602-07-15-ce-what-if-season-3-episode-8-the-avengers-assembled-in-1602
Synopsis
In an alternate universe set in the year 1602, Captain Peggy Carter is summoned by that world's Scarlet Witch to help prevent the reality from collapsing in on itself. She arrives to find familiar heroes and villains transplanted into the early 17th century, serving under Queen Hela... until a rift tears open and pulls Hela through it, leaving Carter blamed by Thor and declared a fugitive.
Forced to operate outside the law, Carter enlists the era's Tony Stark to engineer a solution and teams up with a Robin Hood-styled Steve Rogers and his band of outlaws. Using a Time Stone-powered gauntlet built by Stark, she uncovers the source of the collapsing timelines: Rogers himself, who cracked the Time Stone during a battle with Thanos in the present day and was sent back to 1602 without his memories. Restoring the reality comes at a personal cost, requiring Carter to say goodbye to yet another version of Steve Rogers.
Reality Designation
This story takes place outside the main Marvel continuity: TRN-1093
It also visits 82111.
Reality numbers are Marvel's official designations.
Where a universe has no official number we follow the Marvel Database and use its Temporary Reality Number (TRN-1092). Where there is neither — official or temporary — at the time we watch it, we assign a Snark Industries number of our own (SI-001).
Characters in the Episode
Milestone: Pulled into another universe, sees and losses another Steve
The lynchpin of the episode. She is summoned by Wanda to fix the collapse of this universe. Shenanigans ensue.
Milestone: Witnessed the death of his queen and the rise of a new, more confused regime
Capable Master Spy and member of the court. Always one step ahead.
Milestone: Freed from imprisonment
Found in a cell, attempting a life of solitude and silence, he is forced back into action by Captain Carter.
Bucky, also amongst Roger's men, is ready for the fight at hand. One might say that he and Steve are thick as theives
Milestone: Loses his queen and gains a king with whom he is fiercely loyal
Thor's enforcer. In pursuit of Captain Carter from the start. Also... somehow a "Hulk" called The Freak.
Scott is amongst the group of Roger's men. He is proficient with a sword and an asset in getting Stark where he needs to be.
The butt of the joke. While, yes, he's a prince in title. This episode uses him as a punching bag.
Milestone: Pulled Agent Carter into her world, betrayed her king, and saved the day by doing so
The mastermind behind bringing Captain Carter to save her world. Works with the 'Rebels' to save the day.
Milestone: Pulled into a portal
The catalyst of the episode occurs when Hela is sucked up into the portal caused by Steve.
Milestone: Loses his sister Hela, takes the throne, and nearly loses it
Essentially the antagonist of this story. Attempting the capture and execution of Captain Carter
Milestone: Nicked the Time Stone in a battle with Thanos, was shunted out of time, and nearly caused the collapse of a universe
The leader of 'Roger's Hood', a merry gang of thieves! Also, probably more importantly, "The Forerunner".
A blink and you'll miss it appearance. In the aftermath of their previous mission, Natasha is the only one to witness Carter's disappearance.
Brutal.. but mostly there for atmosphere and for Marvel fans to point at the screen when he appears.
Milestone: Invented the machine that saved his world
The man the makes the machine to save the universe. Literally.
Milestone: Recruits Agent Carter
Not a large part of this story, but, much like his last appearance, he shows in the final moments of the episode.
The reason Steve is there to begin with. Another variant of Thanos from an unknown universe invading Wakanda.
Used as Hogan's enforcer, he attacks Carter in an attempt to appease his king.
The multiversal observer who narrates the divergence and provides the foundational premise.
Comic Roots
Where the episode's people and places come from on the page.
The episode "What If... the Avengers Assembled in 1602?" is explicitly inspired by the eight-issue limited series Marvel 1602, published in 2003 and written by Neil Gaiman with art by Andy Kubert. However, the MCU adaptation takes significant creative liberties, shifting the focus from Gaiman's Silver Age characters to the modern Avengers lineup.
In Gaiman's original comic, Steve Rogers is revealed to have fought against a 21st-century dictatorship led by the Purple Man as President-for-Life, was subsequently captured and sent back in time, was taken in by Native Americans who misheard his name, and upon encountering the struggling Roanoke Colony, helped it survive and became Virginia Dare's bodyguard. In the What If...? version, Rogers is a Robin Hood-style outlaw in England, and his displacement is the result of accidentally striking the Time Stone during the Battle of Wakanda. While the "outlaw" status of Rogers Hood evokes the Robin Hood archetype, Gaiman's Rojhaz was a more somber, culturally complex figure whose presence in the past was a calculated act of political exile rather than an accident.
A note on naming: the Purple Man is referred to as "Kilgrave" in the MCU, a name introduced in the Netflix series Jessica Jones. In Gaiman's Marvel 1602 source text, the character is identified only as the Purple Man. The two names refer to the same character across different continuities.
Gaiman's Marvel 1602 was a foundational exploration of how mutants (called "witchbreed") and the Fantastic Four (the "Fantastick") would be perceived in an era dominated by the Spanish Inquisition and the fear of sorcery. This social commentary is largely absent from the animated episode, which prioritizes the "Avengers Assemble" motif. Characters such as Carlos Javier (Xavier), the Inquisitor Enrique (Magneto), and the crew of the Fantastick are adapted out, likely to maintain narrative focus and to avoid introducing teams not yet fully established in the live-action MCU.
In the comics, Stephen Strange serves as Queen Elizabeth's physician and magician. He is executed by King James following the witchbreed's escape, and his death releases him from the Watcher's oath, allowing his astral form to communicate with his wife Clea and reveal the truth of the temporal anomaly. The What If...? episode replaces Strange in the court mage role with Wanda Merlin. In the comics, Wanda was a nun rather than a court magician. This change allows the series to explore the specific "Guardian of the Multiverse" connection between Wanda and Peggy Carter, while keeping Strange Supreme as a looming figure who appears only in the final moments to drive the overarching season narrative.
Recommended Reading
Where to go next if the episode left you wanting more.
The direct source. One of the most acclaimed Marvel limited series ever published, and the Forerunner twist this episode borrows is its central mystery. Essential companion reading.
The sequel to Gaiman's series, exploring what happens after the 1602 world is stabilized.
Part of the 2015 Secret Wars 1602 revival. Beautifully illustrated entry point to the wider 1602 universe.
A comics continuation of Captain Carter's story exploring her displaced-in-time identity. Directly relevant to the episode's emotional core: Peggy perpetually separated from Steve by circumstance.
One of the best single Doctor Strange stories. A strong companion to Doctor Strange Supreme's arc, a Strange who will sacrifice everything for the people he loves, no matter the cost.
The Snark File
Easter eggs, callbacks and technical tidbits.
Tom Hiddleston and Hamlet
The episode opens with Loki performing the "To be, or not to be" soliloquy while holding a skull at the Globe Theatre. Tom Hiddleston has played Hamlet on stage in real life, making this one of the more pointed pieces of casting awareness in the series.
Loki Is Doing It Wrong
Speaking of Hamlet... There is a subtle error in that Globe Theatre scene that Shakespeare students will clock immediately. In the actual play, the scene where Hamlet holds the skull of Yorick and the "To be, or not to be" soliloquy are two completely separate scenes. Whether this is a production error or a deliberate joke about Loki being a theatrical fraud is left to the viewer.
Cate Blanchett's Role Re-Reprisal
Presumably, Hela occupies the position of Queen Elizabeth I in this reality, and Cate Blanchett has previously played Elizabeth I on screen twice, in Elizabeth (1998) and Elizabeth: The Golden Age (2007). A fun little multiversal parallel, whether intentional or not.
"No. No, I Don't Think I Will."
When 1602 Steve Rogers asks Peggy to tell him about her Steve Rogers, she responds with "No. No, I don't think I will." It is the exact phrasing Steve Rogers uses in Avengers: Endgame when Sam Wilson asks him to explain what happened after he went back in time.
The Flux Capacitor
When Peggy starts throwing 21st-century technical vocabulary at Tony Stark, one of the terms she uses is "flux capacitor," the time travel mechanism from Back to the Future. Stark, who has no idea what she is saying but finds it delightful, does not catch the irony of a time traveler casually namedropping the most famous fictional time travel device in cinema history.
Wakandan Sword
Thor's royal sword is called "the All-Father" and is described as a vibranium weapon gifted to him by the King of Wakanda as a coronation present. It is a throwaway line but a meaningful one, establishing that diplomatic relations between Asgard and Wakanda existed in this reality as far back as 1602, and that Wakanda was exporting vibranium as statecraft even then.
The Episode Started Life as a Victorian Pitch
The episode was originally conceived by writer A.C. Bradley as a version of the Avengers set in the Victorian era, which she pitched when auditioning for the What If...? writing staff. When it was moved to Season 2, it shifted to the 1602 setting to align with the Gaiman source material. Additionally, the episode's structure was directly inspired by holodeck episodes of Star Trek, according to the creative team.