SI Snark Industries
← All Episodes

What If...? · Season 3 · Episode 6

1872?

Shang-Kate-Kwai
Case File
Podcast Release
Jun 18, 2026
Media Release
December 27, 2024
In-Universe
1872 Certain
Reality
Watch Party
30:08
0:0030:08
Deep Dive
15:18
0:0015:18
Join Our Discord

Synopsis

In a rugged, alternate iteration of the American frontier, the legendary gunslinger known as "The Ten Rings," a weathered master martial artist named Xu Shang-Chi, traverses the lawless landscape of 1872 alongside his lethally accurate sharpshooting partner, Kate Bishop. Their odyssey is fueled by a personal quest to locate Shang-Chi's missing sister, Xu Xialing, who disappeared into the "promised land" after fleeing their father's tyranny, only to vanish into the shadows of a burgeoning criminal empire. This journey leads the duo to a decimated township where they encounter Kwai Jun-Fan, a young boy whose community has been abducted by a mysterious "ghost train" that leaves no tracks and vanishes into thin air, signaling a threat that merges primitive frontier violence with anachronistic industrial power.

The investigation uncovers a deep-seated conspiracy involving the sadistic middleman Sonny Burch, who utilizes a fusion of Stark, Hammer, and Cross technology to enslave Chinese immigrants aboard a high-tech, trackless locomotive. The narrative reaches a tragic crescendo when the mastermind behind this exploitation is revealed to be Xialing herself, who killed the original Hood and seized his demon-possessed cloak, allowing its corruption to bend her righteous fury into tyranny. This collision of martial arts, gunslinging, and industrial horror tests the bonds of family. The fallout extends beyond the frontier when Uatu the Watcher's intervention draws the wrath of his peers, leading to his capture and, in his struggle, the shattering of the multiversal wall and the release of three crystals with consequences yet to be fully reckoned.

Reality Designation

This story takes place outside the main Marvel continuity: TRN-1495

Did You Know?

Reality numbers are Marvel's official designations.

Where a universe has no official number we follow the Marvel Database and use its Temporary Reality Number (TRN-1092). Where there is neither — official or temporary — at the time we watch it, we assign a Snark Industries number of our own (SI-001).

Characters in the Episode

Alligator Loki
Alligator Loki Mantle: Loki

A reptilian Loki variant appearing in the multiversal transition.

Kate Bishop
Kate Bishop Mantle: Hawkeye Played by: Hailee Steinfeld (Voice)

Milestone: Discovers the man responsible for her families death and spares him

Kills in this episode: 1

A sharpshooting vigilante driven by a personal vendetta against the Hood's organization, whose enforcers killed her family and destroyed her homestead.

Sonny Burch
Sonny Burch Played by: Walton Goggins (Voice)

Milestone: Loses his budding empire and has his life spared by Kate Bishop

A sadistic weapons dealer and slave-driver using hypnotic Russian tech.

Kwai Jun-Fan
Kwai Jun-Fan Mantle: The Iron Fist Played by: Allen Deng (Voice)

Milestone: Has his entire town wiped out and finds his father amongst the hypnotized passengers

A young boy whose survival triggers the Watcher’s final intervention.

Brock Rumlow
Brock Rumlow Mantle: Crossbones

A variant depicted as a high-seas pirate captain.

Xu Shang-Chi
Xu Shang-Chi Played by: Simu Liu (Voice)

Milestone: Discovers that his sister is The Hood and loses her immediately

Known as "The Ten Rings," a martial master and frontier do-gooder.

The Eminence
The Eminence Played by: Jason Isaacs (Voice)

Milestone: Leads the small contingent of Watchers to apprehend Uatu for his crime of interference

A senior Watcher who captures and punishes Uatu for his interference.

The Executioner

Milestone: Part of the small contingent of Watchers to apprehend Uatu for his crime of interference

A Watcher tasked with enforcing cosmic law against Uatu.

The Incarnate

Milestone: Part of the small contingent of Watchers to apprehend Uatu for his crime of interference

A Watcher presiding over the tribunal that judges Uatu.

Throg
Throg Mantle: Thor

The Frog of Thunder, seen escaping Alligator Loki in a montage.

Uatu
Uatu Mantle: The Watcher Played by: Jeffrey Wright (Voice)

Milestone: Breaks his oath and is apprehended by The Incarnate

The cosmic narrator who breaks his oath to save Jun-Fan, leading to his trial.

Ultron

An Ultron variant programmed for musical theater.

John Walker
John Walker Played by: Wyatt Russell (Voice)

Milestone: Defeated by Shang Chi

A racist outlaw and leader of a posse who attempts to trap Shang-Chi.

Xu Xialing
Xu Xialing Mantle: The Hood Played by: Meng'er Zhang (Voice)

Milestone: Killed by Kate Bishop

Shang-Chi’s sister, corrupted by a mystical cloak into a ruthless crime lord.

Comic Roots

Where the episode's people and places come from on the page.

Overview

The architectural foundation of this episode is deeply rooted in the 2015 Secret Wars event, specifically the tie-in limited series 1872 written by Gerry Duggan. In the comic iteration, the reality is known as the "Valley of Doom", where a version of the town In the comic iteration, the reality takes place in the Battleworld domain known as the Valley of Doom, where a version of the frontier town of Timely is governed by the corrupt mayor Wilson Fisk, with the Roxxon Corporation backing his criminal interests against the town's sheriff, Steve Rogers. The episode adapts the aesthetic of this world, a dusty, lawless frontier where Marvel archetypes are recast as Western tropes, but pivots the character focus to align with the MCU’s Phase 4 expansion.

A second critical literary pillar is the 2015 Master of Kung Fu limited series, another Secret Wars tie-in. This series introduced a version of Shang-Chi as a wuxia-inspired hero living in the domain of K'un-L'un. The "What If...?" writers successfully synthesized these two disparate domains, the Western "1872" and the martial arts "K'un-L'un", to create a story that mirrors the "Eastern-Western" film genre popularized by actors like Bruce Lee and Jet Li.

Beyond the Secret Wars framework, the episode draws from the 2002 limited series The Hood by Brian K. Vaughan. The central plot device, a mystical, demon-possessed cloak that corrupts its wearer, is a direct translation of Parker Robbins’ origin story. By placing this artifact in the hands of Xu Xialing, the writers explore themes of corruption and the pursuit of power that have been part of the character’s DNA since her debut in Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings. The character Kwai Jun-Fan further connects the episode to the deep history of the Iron Fist mantle, referencing the 19th-century Iron Fist introduced in the Immortal Iron Fist run by Ed Brubaker and Matt Fraction.

The Snark File

Easter eggs, callbacks and technical tidbits.

Kwai Jun-Fan

Kwai Jun-Fan is a direct reference to Bruce Lee, whose Chinese birth name was Lee Jun-fan. The episode is set in the same era Lee's ancestors were part of the railroad labor force, and the martial arts throughline connecting Lee to Shang-Chi makes the name choice pointed rather than casual. Kate Bishop's closing comment about his "Iron Fists" then layers a third reference on top.

The Bandanna

Shang-Chi's red bandanna is not generic costuming. The white dragon scale pattern on it is specifically modeled after the Great Protector, the dragon guardian of Ta Lo from Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings. It reads as frontier wear on first glance. On second glance it is his heritage stitched into the fabric.

Point Pegasus

The location John Walker directs them to, Point Pegasus, is a callback to Project Pegasus, the joint SHIELD/NASA research facility that held the Tesseract in Captain Marvel and The Avengers.

"Sun's Getting Real Low"

The line "sun's getting real low" is a callback to Avengers: Age of Ultron, where Black Widow uses it as the verbal trigger to bring the Hulk down from a rampage.

"Iron Fists"

Kate's comment of "That kid's got some Iron Fists on him" is a clear nod to the Marvel character Iron Fist. Immortal Iron Fist #1-16 (2006-2008) by Ed Brubaker and Matt Fraction: Established the Iron Fist as a legacy title held by warriors across centuries. Kwai Jun-Fan IS the 19th-century Iron Fist lineage introduced in this run.