What If...? · Season 3 · Episode 6
1872?
Hello and welcome fellow Marvel fans to the Snark
Industries podcast. I'm John. And I'm Remy. And
we invite you to join us as we work our way through
every Marvel TV show, movie, and crossover. Meaning
if there's a Marvel character on screen, it's
fair game. All categorized in the temporal order
of their setting. By the time we're done, we'll
have built a complete start to finish timeline
of the entire Marvel Cinematic Universe. To accomplish
this goal and to have a bit of fun along the
way, each episode will be split into two parts.
The watch party and the deep dive. If you're
hearing this, you found one of our watch parties.
This is where we sit down with you and experience
a piece of Marvel media together in real time,
celebrating the high points and poking fun at
the low ends, because that's what heroes do.
To get synced up, here's what you'll need to
do. Pull up the movie or episode on your screen
and pause it right as the Marvel logo is prominently
displayed. Then come back here and wait for the
three -tone countdown. On the third tone, press
play, and just like that, we'll be watching together.
Quick note, if your version includes ads, you'll
need to pause us during those breaks to stay
in sync. Once you finish watching along, we encourage
everyone to check out the deep dive as well,
where we will do an in -depth analysis of the
information we just consumed. Most importantly,
we want to thank each and every one of you for
joining us on this incredible journey. We're
not affiliated with Marvel in any way, shape,
or form. We're just fans who are passionate about
these stories and these characters and wish to
share them with everyone in a new and exciting
way. So, sit back, relax, and enjoy this episode
of Stark Industries. Ooh, old -timey Marvel.
I like that. I actually have not seen this episode
yet. Nor have I. I think I stopped the episode
just before. Just shooting the bell. Yeah. The
Wild West. Where's Will Smith? Slapping someone,
probably. It's high noon. Ten rings, huh? I'm
bringing that back already. I was going to say,
we've seen this before. Mm -hmm. Draw! Everything
in the Old West is so epic. Yeah, right? You
rang. It's Shang -Chi. Yeah. Kate? She would
be a gunslinger in the Old West. I was about
to say, yeah. What else would you do with perfect
aim? Oh, damn, that dude's chest compressed a
lot. Well, everyone's dead already. By the time
the hat hits the ground or who's going to catch
it, it's going to land on his head. Oh, that
could be, too. Yeah. Yeah. Place your bets now,
folks. He'll catch it on the other side of the
room. Oh, they're not. They're not killing. They're
disarming everyone. Because that's what heroes
do. I mean. I don't know, man. That's a lot of
bullets to be flying around for. There it is.
Caught it. There it is. Look, dude, if if I just
witnessed that and I'm still on the ground, conscious
and alive, I am playing dead. Hood with a capital
H. Mm hmm. Mm hmm. Is this before or after they
cast that guy? Oh, Hamilton, dude. God, what
is his name? Hamilton, dude. The music's very
different this time, too. Oh, yeah. Oh, operatic.
Wait, who the hell is Jason Isaacs playing? I
love that guy. Shouldn't you know? I suppose,
but he's not. I mean, to my knowledge, he's never
been an MCU character. So he must be somebody
random, somebody new or filling in for somebody.
I don't want to want to. I don't want to know
what if. Sure you do, buddy. I do like Westerns,
though, so this is this might be the tie in that
I need. It is wild how much we vary in our tastes.
Well, you know, together we're like a whole person.
It's a whole person. Ah, Thor frog. Yeah. Frog
Thor. What was his official name? I forget. Frog.
I feel like he wouldn't have been satisfied with
that. He's a performer at heart, truly. Zhou
Zhai Ling. The 1860s is not a great time to come
to America, to be fair. No. No, it is not. Special
with fools like that around. Well, good for her.
Oh, didn't work out. Oh, so she's the hood now.
Wow. Spoilers. Well, again, I have not seen this
episode. I'm just, you know. It's like catching
the hat on the other side of the room. I like
the vibe. I'm feeling it. Shoot the bell. I need
more of that. They need to work on getting that
city fixed up a little bit. A little bit of disrepair.
That might be. Oh, I can't remember the actress's
name. All of a sudden, Haley something. No, that's
Carter. I can't remember. Well, I'm glad we got
to the bottom of this mystery. Yep. But I think
that's the actress that plays Kate Bishop. That's
what I'm saying. Well, it literally is. She's
playing Kate Bishop right now. Whoever it is.
Well, hey, Anthony Hopkins was not Odin in the
last one. Anybody who plays Kate Bishop is the
actress that plays Kate Bishop. You know what?
Kate Bishop -ception. That's cool. The red hood.
I like the way they've made his face look all
swirly. Yeah. A deal's a deal. Who else's eyes
would you have seen it with, kid? I've seen it
with somebody else's eyes. Well, you're like
four. Go home. Home is behind him, dude. I don't
know that he has a home. Listen, just because
it needs to be fixed up a little bit doesn't
mean it doesn't exist. No, just, you know, by
himself. Hey, I'd be king for a day, you know.
I want to see Kate with like a repeater rifle.
Drunken wasp sting. Oh, yeah. Wasp. You can't
have a Western without the horse bucking back
into the sun. Rear and back. Yeah. Yeah. Red
Dead Redemption arc. God, I hated those games.
Oh. So terrible take. Terrible. Yeah. I'm sorry.
Once again. Not a fan of spaghetti Westerns.
You're not. Spoiler. That looks just like nothing.
Oh, they're in time. They're going to see a ghost
train. It's going to be a writer on top of it.
We're going to get a sudden ghostwriter crossover.
I'll throw up if that happens. The punishment
fits the crime. That would only be great if it
were Nick Cage as the voice. I feel like a ghost
train wouldn't be that predictable. Just throwing
it out there. You also was so far up there. There's
no way in hell you're catching that thing. Right.
I wonder how we got that forearm strength. Let's
calm down. Yeah. Yeah. Shane. See, it's not a
ghost train. Phrasing. Yeah, it's a tech train.
They can fly. Yeah. I sincerely hope those. OK,
good. I'm glad they showed those horses breaking
off. Oh, man, I'm hyped up. Them Duke boys. Well,
where's Daisy? Get her on here. Oh, Natasha Romanoff
is Daisy Duke. I'm going to need a little banjo
to play before that. Is that arc reactor? Yeah.
Oh, we got Stark. Yep. Yep. Yep. Yep. He's always
doing stuff. Oh, hammer steel. Did I not say
that she needs a repeater rifle? Give it to her.
No, that's not creepy. That man is some kind
of devilry. I love how he's doing a bit of a
drawl. Yeah, yeah. We need to have a word. Chinese
drawl. It's so good. Yeah, I'm here for it. Fists
of Fury. He's got the accent down, right? Mm
hmm. Trust me, I'm an expert. It seems like it.
Mm hmm. Conscripted. Well, I'm convinced. Yeah.
Break out the bangles. I like that line. I mean,
I'm not a bad guy. Shut up. Oh, man. The drunken
wasping is punching him in the nards. That would
sting. That man sounds like Colonel Sanders.
Don't mess with the colonel's recipe. That's
my secret, Colonel. Do we all sound the same
to you, Remy? Is that what you're trying to get
at? No, this man sounds like Colonel Sanders
is what I'm saying. Oh, man. Killed a kid. Oh,
come on, Colonel Sanders. Full evil. Yeah, man.
That's like one of the things. That's one of
the understandings. Jolly and leave the kids
alone. Damn. I want to back. There's an impress
with them trying to kill a kid. As am I. Right?
I'm sorry, if I'm a bad guy in that situation,
the kid's just getting yeeted. I'm not going
to stare him down for five minutes. Oh, Uatu
intervened. Oh. That's against the rules, Uatu.
That's not a watcher, does. It's called a watcher,
not a pusher. Uatu, the pusher. Yeah, it just
doesn't have the same ring to it. No, it really
doesn't. No, they made it to this area. Someone's
got to go out there every night and light all
those lanterns. I actually really enjoyed the
Hawkeye show with Kate Bishop. Yeah. We'll get
there. Yeah. Looking forward to it. One of these
years. Yeah. A few hundred episodes. Oh, I like
that voice. Uh, no. Sister. You have a twin sister.
Yeah, this is emperor vibes here. Oh. Wow. Oh,
he broke one of his little lanterns. Oh, Satan,
now look. Snow's catching on fire. What kind
of world are we living in? Listen, they just
drove on a train that flew over a chasm. I don't
know if we need to start arguing with the physics
of this episode. Fair enough. I'm just a guy
with a bow and arrow. None of this makes sense.
I know that voice. We're going to figure this
out for later, who that is. Colonel Sanders.
It's not. First of all, he's dead and more worried
about fried chicken. Isn't isn't Colonel Sanders
kind of like Lassie? I don't think he is. Just
replace him. I don't think he is. Oh, man. You
got a little tune in your pocket watch? It would
be really hard to do martial arts in jeans and
cowboy boots. Right. He's definitely blown out
two or three seams of those things. Yeah. So
does he have to come become visible to hit him
or is that just for effect? Either that or he's
just being extra, which is the bad guy MO to
be fair. That's true. You know who it sounds
like? It sounds like Walter Goggins. Oh, it does.
It does. That might be him. That's a good call.
I like how the snow is just disappearing. Is
that Walter or Walter? Am I dumb? Walton. Walton.
Walton. Yeah. Sorry, Walton. I said your name
wrong. I know you're listening. Ah, see? See?
Who called it? Well, I said spoilers a long time
ago, and now everyone's mad at me. As is their
right. No, a prediction is not a spoiler. Damn.
Oh, she about to break out of it and break your
neck, sir. Yeah, I'm convinced. Seems it. Well,
this ain't you. Oh, dude, you nailed it. That
is Walton Conaghy's. See? Yeah. That's actually
low -key kind of awesome. That's pretty rad.
Yeah. Oh, man. Because that's what heroes do.
Mm hmm. Oh, ten rings coming right up. Yeah.
3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10. Well, apparently it
wakes everybody up. 12, 13. Yeah, no, this is
something different. They don't need to summon
Shang -Chi. He's already there. Yeah, but I mean,
come on. That'd be a solid way to wake him up
and snap him out of it. Oh. I love the bad guy
thing where they all just stand there and get
killed. I know. Everyone's waiting their turn
to fight. Yeah. Every one of those guys was standing
there with guns trained on her that entire time.
And somehow she snapped out of her hypnosis,
grabbed her guns and killed all of them before
they fired a single shot. They were just that
surprised. Yeah. Yeah. I like the detail on that
gun. That's cool. That's her mama's goons. Pistol
whip. God, that hurt. I don't know that I've
ever felt a hit in a cartoon. The power of love.
It's over here growling. We'll see this as a
common theme as we go through these shows and
movies. Yeah. Luckily, that fire they started
a few minutes ago didn't do anything. Just background,
man. Yeah. Look at those dancing flames. Oh.
She's fine now. The hood fell off. Is he going
to put the hood on and get revenge? Nah, he wouldn't.
See, she's fine now. The hood corrupts. Mm hmm.
Oh. Moment of silence. OK, it's over. Yep. I
didn't take one second to look at her face and
see that that was, you know. Her. How would she
have known still? Well, you knew 30 minutes ago.
Well, yeah, that's because that's how stories
go. Look at that. Look at that hood. Just find
some other victim. Yeah. It's going to go find
Matthew McConaughey. All right. All right. All
right. Iron Fists. That's Little Danny. I don't
think so. No, I don't either. Uh oh. Oh. Easter
egg. I understood that reference. Man, we're
so cool. Oh, into the sunset. Yes. Looks like
they're trying to hold hands. They are. It's
cute. That's Jason Isaacs. Oh, now he's in trouble
for being the pusher. Oh, shards of whatever
that is have gone into the ether. See, those
are the shards that Harry Potter picks up in
the movie that they never explain. Yes. Tie in.
All right, folks, we will see you over in the
deep dive. Dive in deep. Thank you for joining
us in this episode of the Snark Industries podcast.
To join the conversation and further explore
the Marvel Cinematic Universe with us, head on
over to snarkindustriespod .com. The link will
be in the show notes. But with that, we will
see you in the next adventure. Well, well, well.
The American West, 1872. Shang-Chi is hunting a villain known as the Hood, who has taken his sister Xia Ling. Riding alongside Kate Bishop, and, eventually, Kwai Jun-Fan. With a tip from John Walker, the trail leads to a ghost town with one survivor and a story about a phantom train. They find it, board it, and discover a carriage full of entranced passengers under the control of Sonny Burch, a smooth-talking associate of the Hood who uses a hypnotic pocket watch to keep them compliant. The Hood's stronghold is at the end of the line, and the confrontation there ends with the reveal that the Hood is Xia Ling herself, corrupted and beyond reason. Shang-Chi refuses to fight her, kneeling in defiance until Jun Fan rings the train bell and breaks the trance over the other passengers. Kate takes the shot, and in Xia Ling's final moments, the real her surfaces long enough to say goodbye. Uatu, watching from a distance, flicks a pair of goons off the top of the train to protect Jun Fan, and for breaking his oath, the Eminence calls him to account.
Dive in further at https://www.snarkindustriespod.com/post/1872-06-15-what-if-season-3-episode-6-1872
Join the conversation at https://discord.gg/mJBCuxffF5
Hello and welcome fellow Marvel fans to the Snark
Industries podcast. I'm John. And I'm Remy. And
we invite you to join us as we work our way through
every Marvel TV show, movie, and crossover. Meaning
if there's a Marvel character on screen, it's
fair game. All categorized in the temporal order
of their setting. By the time we're done, we'll
have built a complete start to finish timeline
of the entire Marvel Cinematic Universe. To accomplish
this goal and to have a bit of fun along the
way, each episode will be split into two parts.
A watch party and a deep dive. If you're hearing
this, you found one of our deep dives. This is
where we slow things down and take a more pragmatic,
in -depth look at a piece of Marvel media. We'll
walk through the full plot, explore connections
to the wider MCU and Marvel comics, highlight
Easter eggs, unpack lore, and of course, give
you our own personal thoughts and feelings. Although
this episode stands on its own, it is designed
to complement the watch party. So, if you haven't
watched along with us yet, we highly recommend
starting there first and coming back here for
the full breakdown. Most importantly, we want
to thank each and every one of you for joining
us on this incredible journey. We're not affiliated
with Marvel in any way, shape, or form. We're
just fans who are passionate about these stories
and these characters and wish to share them with
everyone in a new and exciting way. So, sit back,
relax, and enjoy this episode of Stark Industries.
Hello, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the
deep dive. We just watched What If? 1872, Season
3, Episode 6. John, you want to give us that
rundown? Absolutely. And I'm going to preface
this by saying I'm excited about this one. I
didn't know we were in for a Western, and we
got a Western, which is one of my favorite genres,
actually, of all time. So, just going to dive
right into it. This is set in 1872, following
our chronological timeline of when all of these
things were to have taken place. We've got Uatu
sort of explaining this. What if sort of scenario,
you know, across the board is showing different
things. And we get this introduction here as
some cowboys are shooting a bell exactly 10 times
to get 10 rings. Shang -Chi shows up. We have
a cool fight scene there. Introduced to sort
of this setup of racial discrimination in America
in the 1860s, which was a... Really a prime time
for that and everything. And so we, you know,
we get the villain set up as being the hood and
Shang -Chi and Kate Bishop are looking for him.
And after this scene, we get some information.
John Walker's here, too, who gives them a little
bit of info in terms of a town that they can
go and try to find the hood who ultimately they
feel like has. And the reason Shang -Chi is here
to start with has taken his sister. Zha Ling.
And they get to this town and it's in ruins.
It seems like everyone is either dead or gone,
minus one kid who was still around, Jun Fan,
and tells them that there's a ghost train. And
this ghost train somehow is tied into the hood.
So they all mount up, they go out, they find
this train, are able to run it down. It appears
that it is made out of some sort of Stark technology.
We can see some arc reactors and watch it fly
over a big chasm, which was... Really cool. And
in there, we find all the people from this town,
perhaps other places too, sort of entranced sitting
in the seats of this train. They're not reacting
to any sort of external stimulus. And they find
a character by the name of Sonny Birch, who seems
to be sort of in charge of the hood's expeditures
out there. And funny enough, for those that were
with us in the watch party, I called said it
was voiced by Walter Goggins, which is totally
wrong. And so I'll eat crow here and say that
I messed up. But Walton Goggins, who really does
that that accent very well and says, you know,
hey, no reason to fight. You want to find the
hood. The hood wants to find you. Let's have
a meeting. So they take the ghost train and go
to ultimately, I guess, where the hood's HQ is.
And Hood comes out, you know, has Shang want
to join him and everything. And a fight ensues
between it. Only sometime in them exists it to
be revealed that the Hood is actually his sister
that he's been looking for, Xia Ling. Dun, dun,
dun. Yeah. In the meantime, Kate is on the train
still and is being hypnotized by Sonny Burch,
which is this sort of song from this pocket watch.
That is apparently how he has gotten control
of all the other passengers on the train anyway
and was doing it to her as well. Shane ultimately
decides that he can't fight his sister. She's
not listening to reason. So he kneels down and
basically poses the idea that if you want to
kill me, you're going to have to do it while
I stand here defenseless, which is a very heroic
act. In the meantime, seeing the hypnosis happening.
Jun Fan goes and rings the bell on the train,
which apparently is enough to awaken everyone.
Kate's able to grab her pistols and clear out
everyone, knocking out Sonny Birch. And then
as Xia Ling is going to actually kill Shang -Chi,
she doesn't hold back, which surprised me. I
thought that that was going to be how they did
it. She's actually going to go through with it.
Kate is able to shoot and ultimately kill her
before so. And in doing so, the hood is removed.
And as she's having her dying breaths, has a
nice tender moment with Shang -Chi, who is able
to reunite, at least for a few brief moments,
with what is actually his sister. You know, the
real one. Yeah, not the one that has been corrupted
by the hood. We see the hood sort of flying off
in the breeze. And then at the ending, we have
Uatu and the other Watchers. have a brief scene
as Iwatu earlier on while they were on the train,
saved Junfan from some goons by flicking them
off the top of the train, breaking his oath to
be a watcher and being impartial. And the eminence
steps before him and says, this has gone on long
enough. We cannot handle any more of your interference
and is punishing him in some way. And we see
little bits of shards of. The hallway in which
all of these what -if scenarios are sort of taking
place in flick off into the ether, which I assume
will have some sort of repercussions down the
road. One would imagine. But yeah, that was the
breakdown that we had in terms of tie -ins to
the MCU. I feel like we've broken record here
a little bit with this, with these what -if episodes,
as in it doesn't really have any major ones because
it's a what -if episode. It's a separate designation.
In and of itself, of course, we do get to see,
and I actually really enjoyed seeing the Watcher
do something. And then, you know, I remember
when it happening, watching it, like, I was like,
man, he's not supposed to do that. But they actually
address it. So I think that is interesting. Maybe
doesn't tie into the MCU in general, but shows
perhaps a way that, you know, because the theory
is, of course, that the Watchers are always out
there. why they aren't interfering in any other
affairs anyway, because they tried that back
in the day and Uatu got in trouble. So in terms
of tie -ins go, that's probably the major one
that I see, you know, and everything else is
just, of course, just the characters themselves
in a different scenario, Wild West scenario versus
their standard settings. But how about comic
books, Remy? Anything specifically where they
tie in there? Yeah, actually, there are quite
a few comic routes in this one. This one is rooted
in the 2015 Secret Wars events, specifically
tied to the limited series of 1872 written by
Jerry Duggan. The reality is known as the Valley
of Doom and is in domain six on Battleworld.
So kind of cool. I believe this is the same reality
that the old man Logan takes place in. So that's
the main. comic source and then it also takes
a page from 2015's master of kung fu limited
series which is another secret wars tie -in and
the 2002 limited series the hood by brian k vaughn
obviously that is the origin of that character
and uh that's what we get from that and this
episode takes place in the the designation is
earth trn1495 But the comic origin, if you care,
is Earth 51920. Well, I can't. So those are the
those are the comic origins. And as far as Easter
eggs are concerned, there were a ton of them
that I caught. We got the sun's getting real
low. Obviously, the ten rings. We heard stark
munitions, hammer, steel, cross manufacturing.
So all three are characters that we know. The
Fist of Fury. We saw Throg. We saw Alligator
Loki. There was mention of Kate Bishop's family
history being rich. There was John Walker, who
was also played by what's his name? Russell White
Russell. Yep. Wyatt Russell. Just a ton of things
thrown at this one. And I that was a ton of fun
watching them all come through. So what do you
think of the episode overall? I know you kind
of already mentioned it, but yeah, I'll get that
one second. I actually wanted to add a couple
more of the Easter eggs that I know. Yeah, by
all means as well. Uh, all the ones you did,
of course. Great. We also had, uh, them talk
about June Vaughn being, uh, having iron fists,
which I thought was interesting. Yeah. Especially
after just recently watching one of the iron
fist. What if episodes? Oh, that reminds me.
Uh, June Vaughn is actually an iron fist and
given the timeline, it actually lines up with
when he is the iron fist. So that's really cool
too. Sorry to interrupt. Carry on. Uh, and we
also in the hallway with Uatu walking, we had,
uh, in addition to the Throg and alligator Loki,
we had, uh, a high seas version of crossbones,
which was pretty cool. And Ultron as a show tunes
robot. That's right. That's right. Yeah. So that's
pretty great. Yeah. Lots of, lots of Easter eggs
in this one, uh, which was kind of fun. So, but
thoughts and feelings, you know, it's funny.
Uh, I have to, I have to. turn on my own standards
here. I've been talking a lot about how I haven't
liked the What If series thus far. And I got
to be honest, man, I really like this episode.
I understand it's standalone. I understand it's
an outside story, but I am impartial to Westerns.
I've always enjoyed them. I have fond memories
as a child watching Westerns with my grandpa.
So perhaps that goes into it. But having that
kind of setting and seeing the characters that
I love in a setting that I really enjoy was really...
Really fun. I thought the story was really well
done. I loved seeing and you know, what's really
funny and we'll get there eventually. This version
of the hood. We see the hood in Ironheart. Ironheart
as well. This version of the hood is. 10 ,000
times better than that one. In my opinion. Oh
my God. I was blown. I was, I was sitting there
like when I seen the hood being the villain here
and I was like, Oh great. You know? And I even
said for those that were with us in the watch
party, I wonder if it's the same guy, you know,
like that was in, that was in the show, which
it wasn't, it was a totally different thing.
And obviously in this case it was, uh, Jolene,
but I was just like, man, you know, the voice
that they used, uh, the, you know, sort of the
demonic voice they used while they were talking
the. Power set and what they were doing, you
know, the fight scene that they had with the
Hood and Shang, just all just chef's kiss. No
notes on this one. I mean, this is probably the
favorite thing that we've watched thus far here
on the show. Whoa. Okay. Wow. I'm not going to
say it's my favorite Marvel thing ever. You know,
there's a lot of things we haven't got to yet,
but of the things we've watched so far, only
seven episodes in, this one takes the cake for
me. Nice. Yeah. How about you? What are your
thoughts? It's funny because I'm exactly the
opposite. I don't like spaghetti Westerns. I
don't like things that are set in the Old West.
I find it very, very boring, typically. But I
thoroughly enjoyed this episode. I like Shang
-Chi. I really like Kate Bishop as a character.
It was fun. It was a really good adventure. Like
we were saying, there were a lot of comic roots
in here. So it was a lot for me to recognize
and pull from and like, oh, I see what they're
doing. So it was even if I wasn't paying attention
to the Western of it all, which they definitely
made better than your typical Western. There
was a lot for me to enjoy. But I have to agree.
I think this is probably one of my favorite that
we've watched to this point, although I really
did like the I think it was episode three of
Eyes of Wakanda that we've watched so far. That
was that was a lot of fun. That was the Iron
Fist, the Iron Fist one. Yeah. So I really enjoyed
that. But overall, great episode. I again, I'm
with you. No notes. That was a lot of fun. And
just to throw it out there, we kept referring
to the dude that played Hood in Iron Heart as
the Hamilton guy. His name is Anthony Ramos,
in case anybody cares. We'll get there, too.
That's that's on the on the horizon. And I really
look forward to. uh enjoying that that series
again yeah talking about it in the best of ways
but yeah no what i was going to say is that uh
i could easily watch an entire series set up
to be this and be happy oh man if they wanted
to put a whole series a whole season together
of just this i would i would watch it and i would
I would smile on a grateful universe, you know?
Yeah. Same. If they did a full animated battle
world series, looked at old man, Logan, the hulks.
I mean, there are so many good stories in battle
world. This being one of them, man, I'd be all
for it. A hundred percent. Absolutely. Yeah.
At least we got a taste. We got a taste. Sometimes
a little dab will do you. That'll do donkey.
All right, ladies and gentlemen, thank you so
much for listening and we will catch you next
episode. Thank you for joining us in this episode
of the snark industries podcast to join the conversation
and further explore the Marvel cinematic universe
with us, head on over to snark industries, pod
.com. The link will be in the show notes, but
with that, we will see you in the next adventure.
Tanu.
Snark Industries rides into the Old West for What If...? Season 3's 1872 episode, and it lands as the clear favorite of everything watched on the show so far. The full plot gets walked through, from the opening bell-shooting setup that brings in the Ten Rings to Shang-Chi and Kate Bishop tracking the Hood across a ruined town, a ghost train powered by Stark technology, and the gut-punch reveal that the Hood is Xia Ling, Shang-Chi's own sister. Comic roots run deep here, with ties to the 2015 Secret Wars event, the 1872 limited series by Gerry Duggan, the Master of Kung Fu limited series, and Brian K. Vaughan's 2002 Hood origin run all getting their due. Easter eggs are plentiful, including Jun Fan as a timeline-appropriate Iron Fist, Throg and Alligator Loki spotted in Uatu's hallway, Stark Munitions, Hammer Steel, and Cross Manufacturing all named on signage, and a show-tunes Ultron that really has no business working as well as it does. The episode also delivers a meaningful piece of Watcher lore as Uatu's interference draws consequences from the Eminence, setting up something bigger down the line.
Dive in further at https://www.snarkindustriespod.com/post/1872-06-15-what-if-season-3-episode-6-1872
Join the conversation at https://discord.gg/mJBCuxffF5
Synopsis
In a rugged, alternate iteration of the American frontier, the legendary gunslinger known as "The Ten Rings," a weathered master martial artist named Xu Shang-Chi, traverses the lawless landscape of 1872 alongside his lethally accurate sharpshooting partner, Kate Bishop. Their odyssey is fueled by a personal quest to locate Shang-Chi's missing sister, Xu Xialing, who disappeared into the "promised land" after fleeing their father's tyranny, only to vanish into the shadows of a burgeoning criminal empire. This journey leads the duo to a decimated township where they encounter Kwai Jun-Fan, a young boy whose community has been abducted by a mysterious "ghost train" that leaves no tracks and vanishes into thin air, signaling a threat that merges primitive frontier violence with anachronistic industrial power.
The investigation uncovers a deep-seated conspiracy involving the sadistic middleman Sonny Burch, who utilizes a fusion of Stark, Hammer, and Cross technology to enslave Chinese immigrants aboard a high-tech, trackless locomotive. The narrative reaches a tragic crescendo when the mastermind behind this exploitation is revealed to be Xialing herself, who killed the original Hood and seized his demon-possessed cloak, allowing its corruption to bend her righteous fury into tyranny. This collision of martial arts, gunslinging, and industrial horror tests the bonds of family. The fallout extends beyond the frontier when Uatu the Watcher's intervention draws the wrath of his peers, leading to his capture and, in his struggle, the shattering of the multiversal wall and the release of three crystals with consequences yet to be fully reckoned.
Reality Designation
This story takes place outside the main Marvel continuity: TRN-1495
Reality numbers are Marvel's official designations.
Where a universe has no official number we follow the Marvel Database and use its Temporary Reality Number (TRN-1092). Where there is neither — official or temporary — at the time we watch it, we assign a Snark Industries number of our own (SI-001).
Characters in the Episode
A reptilian Loki variant appearing in the multiversal transition.
Milestone: Discovers the man responsible for her families death and spares him
Kills in this episode: 1
A sharpshooting vigilante driven by a personal vendetta against the Hood's organization, whose enforcers killed her family and destroyed her homestead.
Milestone: Loses his budding empire and has his life spared by Kate Bishop
A sadistic weapons dealer and slave-driver using hypnotic Russian tech.
Milestone: Has his entire town wiped out and finds his father amongst the hypnotized passengers
A young boy whose survival triggers the Watcher’s final intervention.
A variant depicted as a high-seas pirate captain.
Milestone: Discovers that his sister is The Hood and loses her immediately
Known as "The Ten Rings," a martial master and frontier do-gooder.
Milestone: Leads the small contingent of Watchers to apprehend Uatu for his crime of interference
A senior Watcher who captures and punishes Uatu for his interference.
Milestone: Part of the small contingent of Watchers to apprehend Uatu for his crime of interference
A Watcher tasked with enforcing cosmic law against Uatu.
Milestone: Part of the small contingent of Watchers to apprehend Uatu for his crime of interference
A Watcher presiding over the tribunal that judges Uatu.
The Frog of Thunder, seen escaping Alligator Loki in a montage.
Milestone: Breaks his oath and is apprehended by The Incarnate
The cosmic narrator who breaks his oath to save Jun-Fan, leading to his trial.
An Ultron variant programmed for musical theater.
Milestone: Defeated by Shang Chi
A racist outlaw and leader of a posse who attempts to trap Shang-Chi.
Milestone: Killed by Kate Bishop
Shang-Chi’s sister, corrupted by a mystical cloak into a ruthless crime lord.
Comic Roots
Where the episode's people and places come from on the page.
The architectural foundation of this episode is deeply rooted in the 2015 Secret Wars event, specifically the tie-in limited series 1872 written by Gerry Duggan. In the comic iteration, the reality is known as the "Valley of Doom", where a version of the town In the comic iteration, the reality takes place in the Battleworld domain known as the Valley of Doom, where a version of the frontier town of Timely is governed by the corrupt mayor Wilson Fisk, with the Roxxon Corporation backing his criminal interests against the town's sheriff, Steve Rogers. The episode adapts the aesthetic of this world, a dusty, lawless frontier where Marvel archetypes are recast as Western tropes, but pivots the character focus to align with the MCU’s Phase 4 expansion.
A second critical literary pillar is the 2015 Master of Kung Fu limited series, another Secret Wars tie-in. This series introduced a version of Shang-Chi as a wuxia-inspired hero living in the domain of K'un-L'un. The "What If...?" writers successfully synthesized these two disparate domains, the Western "1872" and the martial arts "K'un-L'un", to create a story that mirrors the "Eastern-Western" film genre popularized by actors like Bruce Lee and Jet Li.
Beyond the Secret Wars framework, the episode draws from the 2002 limited series The Hood by Brian K. Vaughan. The central plot device, a mystical, demon-possessed cloak that corrupts its wearer, is a direct translation of Parker Robbins’ origin story. By placing this artifact in the hands of Xu Xialing, the writers explore themes of corruption and the pursuit of power that have been part of the character’s DNA since her debut in Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings. The character Kwai Jun-Fan further connects the episode to the deep history of the Iron Fist mantle, referencing the 19th-century Iron Fist introduced in the Immortal Iron Fist run by Ed Brubaker and Matt Fraction.
Recommended Reading
Where to go next if the episode left you wanting more.
The Secret Wars miniseries that gives this story its title and its core conceit, dropping Marvel's heroes into a frontier town in the year 1872. The roster is different (it centers on a Western Tony Stark and a sheriff Steve Rogers), but the idea of a Wild West Marvel pinned to that exact year starts here.
The origin of Parker Robbins, the small-time crook who steals a demon's hood and boots and gains the power to turn invisible and walk on air. Essential background for the outlaw the heroes are hunting, even with the late twist about who is really wearing the hood.
The run that expanded the Iron Fist mythology into a long line of warriors reaching back through history, the tradition the young Kwai Jun-Fan is destined to join.
The modern relaunch that digs into Shang-Chi's family, his siblings, and the secret society that shaped them, useful grounding for a story that turns on Shang-Chi and his sister.
The celebrated run that made Kate Bishop a co-lead and cemented her as one of Marvel's sharpest archers, the foundation for the gunslinging Kate at the heart of this team-up.
The Snark File
Easter eggs, callbacks and technical tidbits.
Kwai Jun-Fan
Kwai Jun-Fan is a direct reference to Bruce Lee, whose Chinese birth name was Lee Jun-fan. The episode is set in the same era Lee's ancestors were part of the railroad labor force, and the martial arts throughline connecting Lee to Shang-Chi makes the name choice pointed rather than casual. Kate Bishop's closing comment about his "Iron Fists" then layers a third reference on top.
The Bandanna
Shang-Chi's red bandanna is not generic costuming. The white dragon scale pattern on it is specifically modeled after the Great Protector, the dragon guardian of Ta Lo from Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings. It reads as frontier wear on first glance. On second glance it is his heritage stitched into the fabric.
Point Pegasus
The location John Walker directs them to, Point Pegasus, is a callback to Project Pegasus, the joint SHIELD/NASA research facility that held the Tesseract in Captain Marvel and The Avengers.
"Sun's Getting Real Low"
The line "sun's getting real low" is a callback to Avengers: Age of Ultron, where Black Widow uses it as the verbal trigger to bring the Hulk down from a rampage.
"Iron Fists"
Kate's comment of "That kid's got some Iron Fists on him" is a clear nod to the Marvel character Iron Fist. Immortal Iron Fist #1-16 (2006-2008) by Ed Brubaker and Matt Fraction: Established the Iron Fist as a legacy title held by warriors across centuries. Kwai Jun-Fan IS the 19th-century Iron Fist lineage introduced in this run.